The Corinthians: An Experiment in Democracy
Episode · Jun 16, 2026 · 52 min
📄 Read the full transcript · Leer la transcripción
There is a direct parallel between the radicalizing of the U.S. women's team and the dressing room and Brazilian society more broadly, right? Because the common thread, like the forest fire began, the forest fire really took off when they connected the authoritarian elements in the dressing room to the wider authoritarian context and people were directly affected. So when Julio talks about there won't be a movement, that's because there might not be the conditions yet for the movement, right?
Because as bad as repression is, the rot is not yet severe enough that it's impossible to ignore. So there needs to be, I think, a radicalizing element. And the reason I mention that radicalizing element as being so crucial is that if you see what it led to, it led to a footballer making a call for a referendum, a vote in the Brazilian Congress. If the vote passes, I think on the 15th of November, if the vote passes, then Brazil gets the right to free and fair elections.
and Socrates, this is the crucial final element beyond the radicalisation, he then does a kind of Muhammad Ali type thing he basically says, if this vote doesn't pass, I'm leaving Brazil so he basically is ready to give up everything that he's built, and this guy at this point, captain of the World Cup team that should have won in 82, it's the greatest team arguably never won a World Cup, he has the height of his powers, intellectually, physically aesthetically, all the rest of it, and he gambles everything, and here's the fascinating thing the last thing i'll say about fascism in a time of victory or failure right the 34 world cup they won that world cup italy and it was the basis of the fascist movement because fascism can be a unifying force but arguably because brazil don't win the world cup because they don't get the big success because he actually you know loses muhammad ali like one of the reasons it's so iconic is because he gave up his prime years right his impact was arguably greater than if he'd been winning and doing all of this. Kaepernick too, because Kaepernick sacrificed and because we all understand that you're an athlete, right? You only get your prime once. So I think all those elements, Julio, to bring it back to not yet, maybe we haven't yet had the radicalizing moment and maybe the radicalizing moment will create conditions where some player or some collection of players from any country go, actually, I'm going to risk it all.
yeah so the thing is about culture right people um and this is not necessarily an american context people are always concerned about oh it's not culture hasn't been around long enough but culture could be established in literally like two or three years um one thing i always look at there's a great spoken word like in berlin called berlin spoken word it's been going for a few years but it's absolutely part of the cultural scene like it's a cornerstone and it's one of the most inclusive progressive forward-thinking spaces you could imagine and in a football context you've got like look the former Yugoslavia when it broke up in Croatia they said football is going to be one of the pillars of our new nation it's going to be like a core element of the new nation and it's who can who can question Croatian football culture as a unique thing two World Cup finals incredible stream of players that's culture and they did it in no time at all so yeah like it doesn't have to be legendary legendary number 10 I love Madre you see it like I see the vision I love him. I love when he was getting older. I just, you know, I root for the older legends when they're still performing on the international stage. And what he has accomplished in recent World Cups were just, I was just like, that is brilliance.
That is... Next level. That's wisdom. That's experience.
That's learning. It's just next level. And yeah, I'm a big fan of his. Always.
Can I just say, actually, the funny thing, actually, on that game, his last game in the World Cup against Argentina, the semi-final. And Merrick, you'll remember this too, it was 3-0. Argentina were 3-0 up and it didn't feel safe for them until Modric went off 10 minutes from the end. Because that guy, he's such a magician.
He could still engineer something. He's that good, he could have made something happen. And Julio, it's funny because as we talk about inclusivity, you're someone who wears a thousand hats. Rebel journalist, soccer dad, Puerto Rican.
Yes, I'm a player. The only one that's still playing amongst the three of us after Merritt's like, why are you playing, dude? Like, I get it. Exactly.
I get it. So, yes, what are you saying, Musa? What is the point? I'm going to come to you because you're someone who appreciates, like, the diversity of life.
And the next episode is going to take us in a time travel machine forward from the Algerian independence movement to Brazil, actually. And Brazil, I think, is a country and a context which I think would satiate all your kind of different areas of passion. So it's a country that is very much about family and community, rather than yourself. It's got a rich history, lots of overlapping racial histories, some good, some bad.
The minority experience within a wider sort of, rather like the US, it's a continental nation, right, in terms of the scale of it. So I'm going to come to you actually, I think quite early on. But before we do that, we're going to recap. Thank you.
We're going to recap. Yeah, let's recap. I got takes. I got takes on Brazil.
Yes, thank you. I can't hear that. In terms of how we're going to run this. We're going to buckle up.
yeah right so how we're going to run this episode is i'm going to take us through a kind of sweep of the story in brazil i won't give too many spoilers we'll get into it but we're going to go through the story of a very particular moment in brazilian history and as we go through this story i encourage you both to leap in with questions uh all i ask is that you raise a hand so i can come straight to you oh mr musa it's the class well professor musa i didn't know like we were like hello so how do you want the hand raised like like this well no just like you can space your voices out and i might i might i might throw a question to you if you want to jump in and put a hand up otherwise i'll just throw a question to you very like we're going to class this this time travel this is awesome this this time travel is refined this is a refined time travel i want to make sure i keep passing the rock you know equally between everyone got you i love this so yeah like we've been jumping around a bit we started off in italy obviously in 34 we jumped over to algeria i see what they were they were cooking up over there now we're going to jump across the ocean again to brazil and the reason we're here in 1982 a lot's gone on since the 50s actually we've had the curtis mayfields we've had a series of assassinations of leading progressive political figures obviously the cold war some would say it's still ongoing in 82 very much it's a live issue but julio where we go first of all is a movement called the corinthian democracy movement is this something you know about yet do i have to raise my hand to like answer it or you're just asking me like i was like no no here's the thing all right i'm just gonna totally say this because i studied latin american history and literature during my undergrad years and one of the things that is very clear about latin america is that brazil is perhaps one of the most misunderstood, understudied areas of the region. Because, you know, when you think about Latin America, and you think Spanish dominant, and you tend to forget that Portuguese and this country in literally in the middle of the continent, has such a massive influence. But I did not grow up understanding or following Brazilian history. I grew up more in like, you know, studying Argentine history, Mexican history, Chilean history, like all the countries around it, Venezuela and Colombian.
And Brazil was always even when I studied in school, Brazil was always like this. Oh, yeah, by the way, this happened in Brazil, there was a dictatorship in the 60s, and blah, blah, blah, in the 70s, and all that. And you're like, okay. And so I kind of discovered Brazil later in my life, because of where I live, which is Massachusetts, which, you know, don't quote me 100% on this, but there is a thriving Brazilian community in Massachusetts.
And I believe that it's the second largest Brazilian immigrant population in the United States by state. And I do know this, that out of the current immigrant base, people that have recently arrived or are beginning to establish their status in the United States, Brazilians are the top immigrant group in Massachusetts. Okay. So I've learned Brazil through the pitch, because as you know, I think I've mentioned before, but I will say it again.
I keep saying it and Merritt's like, don't play. But I've been playing like old man soccer since I was like, you know, my late 30s, early 40s. And the amount of immigrant Brazilian teams that I have played against, whether it's in places like Framingham, which is sort of out west of Boston, or places like Brockton, which is south of where I live, just like 15, 20 minutes. I've seen like these older Brazilians.
I mean, I'm talking about people who are like 62 playing in over 40 leagues. And I'm like, you played first division in Brazil because you can't be this skilled and play at 62. You talked about, to pick up your point about talking about discovering Brazil through football, we're going to discover Brazil through the dressing room, because that's where this next episode begins to take place. So we're in 1982.
Some context on Brazil, the scale of Brazil, the state of Brazil at the time, the scale of Brazil, first of all. So Brazil is, I live in Germany, which is a big country, fairly big country. So Brazil is basically almost 25 times the size of Germany. Brazil is just over 10% bigger than the continental USA.
So excluding Hawaii and Alaska, Brazil is bigger than continental US. It's a huge, huge country. And The reason why I like to compare Brazil to the US in a certain way is all the range of the climates you have within the US, Yellowstone Park, all the rest of it, you have similar elements in Brazil. So actually the two countries map onto each other geographically in quite an interesting way.
And also you've got the American interior, right? You've got the country music, even down to the country music scene. You've got a huge thriving Brazilian country music scene. So the context is that there's actually a lot of similarities.
slavery in its transatlantic form is understood from chattel slavery was the last place brazil was the last place to end in 1888 the other thing is in terms of the football context obviously the greatest brazil player ever is pelle uh mara argue the greatest oh oh wait wait merit's like checking you you're gonna say garincha or no i said martha well do you know what the only reason i would say that pelle is great is because we always respect the ancestors um and that's the The only reason I would say that Messi was greater than Maradona because the path was laid. If Marta came before Pelé, we take it. Some would argue, actually, in Pelé's case, some argue that he wasn't even the greatest men's player. Some say it was Gorincha.
Some say it was Didi who played at Real Madrid for a year. So, absolutely. But I always respect the ancestors. But, see, 1982, Brazil, huge country, but going through some serious changes at the time.
This episode is set. So at the time this episode set, there was a military coup, I think, about 18 years prior. And since then, Brazil had been under five successive dictators. One thing that we all know on this podcast is that dictators are good at one thing, and that's dictating.
Not particularly good. Hence the name. Right, you see the vision. Not particularly good at the economic side of things, not particularly good at the human rights side of things.
say like economic you know economist it's dictator a trash so at the time this episode takes place they're about three years into a dictatorship by joao figueredo and all these dudes seem to look the same by the way it's really wild it's like like an algorithm just pumps them out he's kind of like oh yeah the military like that's the one thing once i really started like looking at brazilian history and kind of saying like wait a minute there was a Like there were military dictatorships in South America at the same time. And, but the Brazilian dudes, like, it's exactly what you said. It's like, who are these guys? But they all look like, you know, it's like, here's your uniform.
Here's your, here's your dictator uniform. Like here's the dictator playbook. Like go get them, you know? And I do will say, Musa, I know as you tell this story, because of my connection, so many Brazilians are in Massachusetts.
it's I've asked these Brazilians my generation like why'd you leave like you lived under a dictatorship like how was it and this is what they all told me and I've talked to 10 of them since the first Trump administration more than 10 like I've always asked this one question and they said I'm living in a country right now the United States of America where I'm reminded so much of being like you know a 10 year old kid during a military dictatorship in brazil and those when you start talking to people who have lived under dictatorship in a different time and now they're living in the united states and they're like i've seen this before seen it before and i'm like and that you know i and that's been to a t i've and and and we don't talk politics on the pitch, but maybe like after when we, we do a little post game, sorry, that's the other reason like I, you know, we talk, but it's, you know, we're hanging out having a couple beers talking, and I just would ask them and then they would open up like these like 40 15 year old men, who were kids, who were kids, like growing up under a dictatorship. And they said, I moved here for the American dream. And I've built, like a life for my family. And I'm so proud of my kids are getting in their education, they're going to American universities, like I've signed up for it but now like this reminds me of brazil which i'm like brazil during the dictatorship and i'm like whoa so i just need to funny thing yeah no so to that point it's funny to mention this because in the period after dictatorship comes in it's not immediately awful for everyone right so rather like when you know trump got in first and second time or second time in this case because this is really the dictatorship we're talking about trump got in the second time and some people doing really well out of it actually because for some people trade really opened up and actually there was a spike for a certain section of the population who saw their pockets lined quite well but then as in brazil in the mid-60s you had this sort of high growth and then it was hit by debt hyperinflation we're seeing some inflation now with some of mr trump's adventures abroad so at this point and the thing about dictatorship julio and i'll come to merit as well because this feels relevant to her too the thing about a dictatorship it affects every aspect of civilian life right so structures begin at a political level to be authoritarian and then it trickles down across society so all of a sudden if you've got like a top-down system at the highest presidential level the state level then day-to-day life be it the office life be it the cultural life starts to resemble authoritarian structures and what was so radical about socrates the hero of this episode an incredible footballer born in North, he came south to play for Corinthians in Sao Paulo.
What was amazing was that Socrates basically said, I'm going to create a democracy in my dressing room with my players. So he gets together with a couple of friends of his who, like himself, it has to be said, it helps that they were also aesthetically very pleasing, very much sort of alpha males, very well read. Socrates was a qualified doctor, very smart guy, read philosophy, super smart. And Merit, I don't know if you had a similar structure in your dressing rooms, but what he said was, we're going to have democracy where we vote on everything we're going to vote on everything from the time we should have meals we're going to vote on how long we should spend in a training camp the night before games just every decision was taken out of the hands of the coach and put into the hands of the players a collective structure and this was so radical because it was unlike anything else that existed in civilian life at the time was that similar to anything that you had in your playing days Merrick yeah my first question is was there something that incited this change was there something that happened that there was even possibility that there would be this entrance of a democracy within the locker room?
It's a great question. I think what incited I think was a general exhaustion, right? So they've been under what dictatorship for almost 20 years now. Yeah, it's it's deep.
Right. And there was no choice. There's no alternative. So Brazil didn't have like even a two party system.
It was like having one meal at lunch. And that was it, right? You're offered like, you know, a side of greens, and that's it. No seasoning, nothing.
Yeah. And I think that the i think the social economic conditions were quite fertile ground to allow this to happen because socrates was pushing a bit of an open door it was like you know incredibly talented player people respected seen as quite a fair-minded dude highly educated but never rubbed anyone's face um never up his privilege anyone's face was kind of like yeah i've got other options but i just really love playing football and the only reason i'm becoming a doctor is to please my dad because my dad does want me to grow up broke so i think he came into it as a good faith actor and he was seen I think quite favorably and I think as well like because his team because he was a really good footballer it was almost like I think it helps if you're just good on the pitch and I think it helps that his team was having a measure of success they were like hang on a minute if we've been this successful listening to him so far on the pitch if we listen to him off it maybe that can kind of have an impact too so I think it was a mixture of his own personal charisma his own talent but also what was going on more broadly politically in the country at the time yeah so there was no coaching change there was no abysmal season there was nothing that like generated this like concept that maybe something something could be different i mean the team he came into was a reasonably good team i don't know if the team long term doing well or badly would have had a huge impact i think it helped that when he joined there was a sharp uptick in the quality of the performances and also there's the fact that he wasn't also training he wasn't training full-time because he was studying but he was he was basically coming in part-time he was given special dispensation he was coming in part-time and it was like hang on this new guy's really really good and you could just tell us as much time as you can yeah he has as much time like this guy even part-time is honestly i don't know how much you've watched of socrates but like there's a video if you go on youtube and there's um there's a highlight called socrates most elegant player ever and this guy is just it would be very difficult to find a Hollywood actor better looking than Socrates to play young Socrates like it would be a real challenge because you'd have to get someone like poor Wagner Mora would have his work cut out like it's a real problem like that's Wagner's a good looking dude but Socrates is like he's an epic yeah he's gorgeous like he's quoted everywhere so yeah I think that helped Merit I think that helps I ask this because I I think there's so often this need for change when there's tension that is felt consistently. And at some point, those results, you can have winning results, but there's a time that it quickly declines when there's like a need for control from a coach, from a technical staff that typically works what you see, typically works on young players with like very little kind of autonomy in their career and decision-making. I saw this in my career back in the NWSL.
it's very early on, you could have environments where it was very authoritative. And so typically, it operates in a way that, all right, I'll stay in line, I will do this thing, I don't want to get in trouble, I don't want to be yelled at, it may or may not affect your playing time. But at the end of the day, there's typically a growth that happens within the team, that it becomes very apparent that these asks are rooted in control. They are not rooted in ensuring the success of the team, if that makes sense.
Yes, yes, yes, of course. And so I think you often come and see these like massive changes or this, this ability to find a unified voice within locker rooms when that tension with your life is so disruptive. And when results start to go a different way, or there's someone in the room that's able to bring a voice and say, that's not right. This is not okay.
And you start to gain momentum. There is nothing more powerful than a unified team with a unified voice with power in their messaging. And what it can create is this, like what we see here, what you're telling us that we see is that we're going to bring democracy to the soccer room. We're going to bring something we haven't seen before, because this is no longer working for us.
This has such an impact on our day-to-day lives that it's not worth the sacrifice of being able to play a soccer game. I've actually had a thought. This connects something that as you talk about, like, you know, why was this such an effective message? And maybe Julio, as someone who's got a background in kind of community organizing and like, you know, community-based work, maybe you can help me on missed so you look at mayor mamdani right i think all people that have an effective political message have got some kind of like founding story like a story where the eyes weren't on them and they were getting something done away from the kind of current context so mayor mamdani look at him and he had the hunger strike with the cab drivers right to get them a fairer deal and before socrates arrived at corinthians i just wonder if he had a bit of a founding legend of his own so when he was over in i think he was playing in rio for botafogo right botafogo you know obviously a big a big club in rio he scored a winning goal against sao paulo who are corinthians hated rivals and he was the top scorer in the league that year and he arrived at corinthians as this kind of like giant killer he had like he was already a hero he's like oh you guys you're the guy that beat sao paulo in his spare time while he was studying like the medical school right so that you arrive in the dressing room and that's already your energy you've done something which a lot of people on your new team haven't done yet like you beat sao paulo and you're coming going actually guys well that's just we're just getting started yeah i mean first of all we're talking about soccer in brazil yeah let's start there that is oxygen i have yet to meet any brazilian and i'm talking people that i did not expect to be soccer fans who when the world cup happens they are wearing the class i mean can we just say the most classic jersey like kit like ever like the yellow green like i'm like don't ever change it like don't do these different so when you see the classic yellow and the green and you see people who i mean i have friends of mine who are like i didn't know you were a soccer like i didn't know you were a brazilian soccer fan right it is just part of life right so yeah but getting to this point about first of all i love the name i mean he's named socrates and it's like come on like you already have like you're like when like when i think about it i remember hearing his name and i did not have the the pleasure of you know i grew up again in the bronx after puerto rico in the late 70s and early 80s and there was not a lot of like you know outside of the cosmos that's pretty much all the soccer that you saw in America or the indoor league, right?
So we weren't getting, unless you were in immigrant neighborhoods or unless you were in Brazilian neighborhoods, you know, there is a little Brazil in New York. Like the rest of New York didn't know what was going on, who Socrates was. When I, so I just read about him as some, you know, 13, 14 year old kid, never saw him play. And I would be like, wow, his name's Socrates.
Like, and the way you explain like how he became a doctor and he's like, all right, I got to play. I want to play football. I want to play soccer. And I'm really flipping good at it.
So I'm going to use my privilege, my intelligence to impact Brazilian culture, because I would argue that soccer is after soccer. What else is... That is it. The history of Brazil is tied to soccer.
It always will be. So to hear this at the time of a dictatorship, we are going to use Brazil's greatest cultural asset. But this notion of Socrates being so perceptive to say like, I'm done. And where can I impact change?
Because I can't change the dictatorship, right? Like that's the one thing people – when you're living under authoritarianism, they're like, well, you know, I can't change this. But you can find the moments where you can change what's in front of you. And that's what and that's one of the things that people say when you live under places where your democratic rights are being removed, that you have to find the little places where you can impact change, whether it's in front of you, whether it's locally, whether and just sort of resist and this is a story of Socrates resisting and I do wonder in this world cup being hosted in the United States with all these high-profile American men like will they say anything and I'm gonna say like no are they but you know I don't know there's something else to throw in which is that I'm trying to think as you speak I'm trying to think of a a parallel because it's always nice to give a context for an American audience of of who Socrates was how big this was so let me put it like this so in terms of the social responsibility that socrates had who would go on to captain the brazil team at the world cup imagine a player the quality of in baseball let's say a shohei otani engulf a a peak phil mickelson you're not giving it to tiger no no because no no because tiger because if i was going to say tiger then it would be pele i think pelle and okay and there's a rank below phil nicholson because okay i get that's a good also the aesthetics the aesthetics of nicholson the style the aesthetics not the politics i i may add but the aesthetics i was like phil nicholson is like you know okay no it's the liberal choice we're discussing aesthetics yeah but the politics and the effective political advocacy of mayor mamdani that that's the layer of what we're talking that's the level we're talking about is the equivalent of what he did with this democracy movement was the equivalent of being a running back breaking away in the closing seconds of the super bowl to score winning touchdown and then turning up to the presidential box going give us our election back give us our country back like it's that to choose his moment of greatest excellence chills turn around and speak truth to power right that that's that's what makes socrates so special and in terms of what he did so this movement was so effective right within the dressing room that expanded outwards because it found resonance with the wider public because they would also wear in their jerseys statements about it's called there's a movement called democracy now basically and we want the right to vote he would he never told anybody how to vote he never said you have to vote left or right he said we need political participation for a better a better nation right rather like the no kings protest basically there are no monarchs here right you're elected by the American people you should be elected by the Brazilian people by analogy so this movement gains so much currency right so much traction beyond the dress room beyond the football pitch they start holding rock concerts so him and his mate Vladimir from the team and his mate Casagrande as well who was the striker they'd go on stage and like they'd read like spoken word pieces about the need for democracy and this thing just absolutely went like gangbusters was was so popular and it's hard to express I think as well like like how cool it was like it was really cool I mean you look at like someone like Marta like Marta is Marta's aura merit it's not just that Marta can play Marta has what they call there's a style of Brazilian people called ginga it's like swag basically like these people had swag you know I have never played with a Brazilian player and not inherently thought you have just this aura, this swag about you, the way that you carry yourself, the way you play on the pitch, the way you embrace life.
But through this conversation, what continues to come up for me is to spark this type of movement, of this type of change. Is one a recognition of an indoctrination of a country, right? They are indoctrinated in loving soccer. And Socrates feels like one of those, you know, characters in history that just understand one, his platform and the power in which that platform can really ignite the fan base, a country.
And, you know, being a soccer player in Brazil means you're a good soccer player, a good looking soccer player. You're likely loved, you're beloved. And I think that is where you start to see this question of the parallel here for me is when we're looking at American sports and the one time that I can continue to reel it back in my history of when athletes really came together, they saw their platform and they're like, okay, it's time to stand for change is when you had the Black Lives Matter movement. If you have Colin Kaepernick kneeling.
And then it becomes, you know, George Floyd is killed through police brutality, Breonna Taylor. And just this overwhelming response from athletes, particularly Black and African American athletes within these leagues in the WNBA that were willing to say, absolutely not, this is not okay. We have to stand for something. This is no longer something that we can turn our backs to and continue to play this game because there is something here that is bigger than us.
And I mean, that movement was powerful. What you saw in both aspects, right? People's support for this movement and wanting to better the lives of Black citizens in America, but also the repercussions of that, of standing for something, what it meant to stand for something to put your platform on display and say, you like me as a basketball player, you like me as a soccer player, but do you like me when I'm willing to speak up against or for something? And I just, you know, you have to question like, can so many of these, these moments in our history of sport be linked back to Socrates and Sao Paulo?
Because even like the Jersey moment, so much of black lives matter is because people are willing to put on a shirt that says black lives matter before a game that was it and that's what people saw they saw it over and over and over again wow yes you know i love that you mentioned this because julia i'm coming to you because i feel like there's a common thread here what merit's saying but if we look at the shirts right there's something iconic those corinthian shirts saying democracy on it and just having that that's sort of constantly having a very simple demand um like it could be cabinet taking the needs it's simple it's symbolic it's iconic and you were talking about like whether anyone will sort of speak up but then socrates i think it was the 86 world cup the next world cup he wears a headband to draw attention to state brutality in mexico that was going on during the tournament i wonder julio what kind of political moments movements what symbols would you like to see or do you think we could anticipate what small gestures of solidarity you think we could see you know this is this summer yeah it's a great question first of all i think we have to acknowledge socrates as understanding his privilege and his moment like saying like you know what if i'm gonna do this i'm gonna do this i love that i don't necessarily think that you know i can name any footballer on any team right now from the i'm talking about the major stars like we have to say that Socrates you know football encyclopedia professor Moussa in terms of top top Brazilian players where would you rank him oh my goodness top five top 10 top 15 top 15 just because the list is that goated yeah understanding that I just said who are the top Brazilian like footballers right so yeah that's like saying like of all these master it's like of like Michelangelo and you know exactly yeah yeah picasso like where do they rank so let's start there and the fact that he is a superstar yes right like there is no he's a football like if you are a successful footballer in in brazil you're a leader you are a cultural icon so i want to put it on that level because I look around and see how corporatized the world cup has become. And I think about when Messi, like in Qatar, like, like wore the robe and you're like, given what happened in Qatar, like Leo Messi's like, Hey, I got a cup. Which I, which believe me, like of all the people I wanted to get a cup and a trophy, Leo Messi's up there. But you don't have athletes right now in the football world, at least I'm talking the level of Mbappe, Messi, Ronaldo.
Even on the American side, I don't think Christian Pulisic is going to be like, yo, democracy now. I don't see it happening because in the end, this is all about the money, money, money. You know what I mean? I'm like, I just broke out into song.
I knew I was going to do it eventually. We started this episode with saying that, you know, these authoritarian fascist governments, for them to gain even the ability to breathe, not everyone can be repressed or feel repressed by them, right? Some people have to do well. And I think when you take this back to soccer and you take it back to FIFA, and I will speak from it from what i know which is a women's soccer lens and because of that the byproduct of that is the u.s women's national team is treated far less fair than their their counterpart which is the u.s men's national team who we mentioned has not won shit i mean come on they haven't won anything they've only been in the round they have only been in the round of 16 once and they lost you It's like they only beat one team in the round of 16.
That was Mexico and Korea. Sorry, I'm playing the role. They've done nothing. Exactly.
So this treatment, which again, we come back to when you start feeling this discomfort, this lack of fairness within an organization, in the way that you're paid, the way that you're treated, the way that you travel, the way that you have hotels on the road, All these things. If that becomes so uncomfortable, what happens? What happens? Because I am now personally affected.
This treatment personally affects me. What does this ultimately do? It unifies the group. And this is what we've seen from the US Women's National Team, because there was such a lack of care for them.
And then on top of it, a lack of pay for being great. It led to this equal pay fight, right? And there was such a core group of activists. You have Megan Rapinoe, Becky Sauerbrunn, Alex Morgan, willing to put their name and put themselves out there to say, hey, we're going to take you on U.S.
Soccer Federation, and you're not going to hide behind FIFA anymore. All this to say, this has moved that signing of that document, moved the needle so far for the current generation that we're seeing. I don't believe it's a surprise that it's the most silent U.S. women's national team we've heard in a long time.
They do not speak on political moments. There's not been conversation around the gouging of ticket prices. There has not been, you know, speaking about DEI rollbacks from this administration when they were in the Olympics, the most diverse team that has ever been. Absolutely.
Yeah. And so I speak from, I give this picture of the women's side because the women's side has moved more towards male professional treatment than we've seen in its entire existence. And on the men's side, I will argue there's a level of comfort. There's a level of protection from access, wealth, ability to make money that keeps them silent, keeps them complacent.
And you don't see that on men's soccer. There's a direct parallel. So the intervention you've made, I'm so glad you've said this, right? There is a direct parallel between the radicalization, the radicalizing of the US women's team, and the dressing room and Brazilian society more broadly, right?
Because the common thread, like the forest fire began, the forest fire really took off when they connected the authoritarian elements in the dressing room to the wider authoritarian context, and people were directly affected. so when when julio talks about there won't be a movement that's because there might not be the conditions yet for the movement right exactly as bad as suppression is the rot the rot is not yet severe enough that it's impossible to ignore so there needs to be i think a radicalizing element and and the reason i mentioned that radicalizing element that's being so crucial is that if you see what it led to it led to a footballer making a call for a referendum a vote in the brazilian Congress, if the vote passes, I think on the 15th of November, if the vote passes, then Brazil gets the right to free and fair elections. And Socrates, this is the crucial final element beyond the radicalization, he then does a kind of Muhammad Ali type thing. He basically says, if this vote doesn't pass, I'm leaving Brazil.
So he basically is ready to give up everything that he's built. And this guy at this point, captain of the World Cup team that should have won in 82, it's the greatest team arguably never won a world cup he's the height of his powers intellectually physically aesthetically all the rest of it and he gambles everything and here's the fascinating thing the last thing i'll say about fascism in a time of victory or failure right the 34 world cup they won that world cup italy and it was the basis of the fascist movement because fascism can be a unifying force but arguably because brazil don't win the world cup because they don't get the big success because he actually you know loses muhammad ali like one of the reasons it's so iconic is because he gave up his prime years right his impact was arguably greater than if he'd been winning and doing all of this kaepernick too because kaepernick sacrificed and because we all understand that you're an athlete right you only get your prime once so i think all those elements julio to bring it back to not yet maybe we haven't yet had the radicalizing moment and maybe the radicalizing moment will create conditions where some player or some collection of players from any country go actually i'm going to risk it all do you believe there's potential that this world cup is a radicalizing moment i think i think the historical context i think what's going on right now is so unprecedented the truth is we just don't know and i would not be surprised either way i would not be surprised if we heard nothing i would also not be surprised if we heard everything i genuinely would not be surprised with all the outlets that athletes have i would not be surprised if someone's catching connecting flight through phoenix and just got on instagram stories got instagram live on a on an hour long you know gap between connecting flights just going this whole thing is a circus i wouldn't be surprised by that either julio sorry i know so much here and you know this notion of what you said merit like the american men the comfort level i i think you have to look this is why brazil is brazil in terms of soccer yes and why the united states is the united states this is life this is oxygen this is you are born in brazil and you know it is it is your dna right again there's plenty of people who have never played the game who just follow the game in brazil who like when i see them when i'm with them i mean when they got when they got like pulverized what was the 7-1 game like like i all i was in group chats with my Brazilian friends and they were like, this is embarrassing. Like there was anger. Right.
So I think you have to start looking at why the American men don't, I don't see the American men like doing anything, but it's because of the American soccer system. Right. It's incredibly privileged. It's incredibly out of reach and expensive for the vast majority of, of young kids, specifically, specifically young kids, like young black kids, young Latino kids, Like there's no, you know, and we're losing that culture.
Do you know when I see Brazilian immigrants and their kids are playing in club or and they're playing in high school or I see in college, like there is a culture there. Like I have yet to meet a Brazilian player who is not smooth, who does not look natural. Like I'm with you, Merit. I'm like, I just sit there in awe whether the person's 18 years old or 67.
And I've seen 67-year-old Brazilian players on the pitch, and I'm like, we can't catch him. We can't get the ball off his foot, right? Like it just doesn't happen. Yeah, they've learned the game through experience.
Because they live with it. So I think this is the problem with – like this is why I don't see it as a moment, and they'll never be, at least right now. Interesting. I'm never going to say never.
They'll never be a Socrates in the American soccer system. But I think it might come through the way the system, the sporting development system is because it's not really – we're losing – I always play this hypothetical. And I will bring up LeBron James because I actually think LeBron James is someone who has tried. I think people forget when Trayvon Martin was killed.
And I know people were like, that's performative. But I remember the Miami Heat all wearing – All purpose is performative. Right. Yeah, but I'm remembering it was like the Miami Heat taking a stand and LeBron James is on that team.
And LeBron James is not Michael Jordan, right? Michael Jordan would never do anything like that. LeBron James has spoken out, right? And so I give credit where credit is due.
But then I wonder, it's like, what if like LeBron James played soccer? What if he was given opportunities back in the day to just enjoy the sport and not have it be attainable? like being attainable, right? Being something that is part of the culture.
I just don't think our American society is thinking that way because it's about winning and putting money and making sure that, you know, 13 year olds are these like technical robots and there's no love of the game. So I think when you have American national players who have been put in this like control system, you're gonna get like guys with no, like i'm sorry like they lack soul like i i don't see a lot of like the beautiful game like the joy the brazilian joy in american soccer in defense of american athletes i think the reason why it happened no and the reason why the kaepernick thing was so impactful i think is because a lot of american men secretly dream of being a quarterback right oh and to see that guy american football is so okay okay i'm glad i'm actually merit maybe i don't know you can add something to this because i'm thinking i've been trying during this podcast to paint a picture. I don't think I've done it successfully yet. From my own mouth, I think you've done it a lot better than I have.
I've been trying to express just how big football is in Brazil, soccer is in Brazil. And I think it's this. I think, imagine going down, imagine walking through any American suburb and everyone is standing on their front lawn and the grandkids are standing there and the grandmothers are throwing perfect 30, 40 yard spirals. Each grandmother is throwing perfect spirals.
And you go, oh, you must have been a college player. they're like no i just i just mess around like and you go to the beach in brazil imagine imagine walking past the basketball court and watching a granddad standing there with perfect form five feet beyond the three-point line and draining a three-point shot until you walk out of sight and you look back over your shoulder and he's still draining threes and you ask them who they are i played football i played football on the great copacabana beach right in 2014 i was covering the world cup there and i play on the beach and there were players there doing things that were astonishing they were running on sand like it was grass barefoot right like running on these jagged surfaces like it was nothing one guy gets the ball picks the ball up you know square beautiful stride kind of socrates like square shoulders broad shoulders looks up smacks the ball 30 yards top 30 meters top corner and i was like who the hell is this guy he was just he was just a civil engineer from sao paulo he was just a regular dude the weight in which soccer holds in the united States is far less than anywhere else in the world, right? And I just find that the need or want to really experience soccer in the way that Brazil wants to experience soccer and the way that it can ignite change in a country like Brazil, as big as Brazil is, you clearly have to understand the importance of what that youth system looks like, what it looks like for a country, what it means for a country to have access to something that brings great joy. And we don't have that here.
We don't have that here on, I guess, from a soccer foundation, right? And so to expect that there might be something that really drives people during this World Cup to have something to say about it or have a stance on it, I just believe is very unlikely. We just aren't indoctrinated with soccer in the same way. We don't live it.
We don't breathe it. And if we do, it becomes so extractive that we don't even know exactly why we're even doing it anymore. There's a thread to draw from this to the takeaways actually from the episode, because I feel like there's a transition. You talk about the extractive nature of soccer in the US actually.
And unfortunately, Brazilian soccer has not been immune to that. So you look now at the Brazilian game, the polarization you see off the field long after Socrates passed he passed in 2011 um yeah in his late 50s long after Socrates passed we're seeing great uh economic and political polarization in Brazil at the moment and we're actually seeing rather like Julio mentioned a lot of the very comfortable very wealthy Brazilian soccer players siding with authoritarian power we're seeing that right now but I think that one thing we're seeing also in a positive context is first of all we're seeing that Socrates lost the battle and won the war. So he lost the referendum, but actually the political pressure that he'd applied because of his stance led to Brazil eventually getting free and fair elections in 84, I think it was. Yeah, it was.
And it's, yeah, it's a young democracy. Yeah, it's a young democracy. Right, exactly. I love that you said that, Hulu, because there's a lot to play for.
So I was just wondering, as we come to the end of this episode and we revere, respect the great Socrates, what lessons, what learnings do you think there are from his political outlook, his political stance? his action what do you think lessons can be taken and maybe applied at some level in a in an american context if any well i think sport can be an instrument for change and speak and speaking out when you have the platform is the time to speak out and again i go back to the fact that socrates you know you said he was good looking he was like he was a white brazilian like he had privilege like he was a doctor like he saw the fact that like i'm going to use my privilege to take this mic and make this happen and and practice democracy in the places that i can participate in in the places not for lack of control in the places that i can influence i can't influence you know if i spoke against the dictatorship in brazilia you know and just show up It's like, you know, I don't think it would have the same effect by bringing it through soccer in Brazil. So I think this notion of the moment and the opportunity and people that do have privilege. And I do think, you know, there's American soccer players that we talked about.
And I'm with you, Merit, like men, the dudes, right? I think you're starting to see this new generation playing in Champions League semifinals and they're playing more in Europe and they're playing in the top tier and they're not playing in MLS, right? So they are the superstars. They are the influence.
They are the next – they were supposed to be the golden generation of we got everything right about American soccer and these were supposed to be the guys. and I just think that we've lost sort of this, like they are just these players who play and won't say anything. I'm hopeful. I hope they surprise me.
I hope someone comes after me in social media a couple months from now and be like, you were wrong. But I do think the lesson of Socrates, it's there and the blueprint is there and history's history and viva Brazil, jogo bonito. I think I said it right Portuguese wise, So those are my thoughts. And I hope people learn about Socrates' story and say, like, it's quite possible.
And I look at the Brazilian context as well as the American one. I think to myself, if I look at, like, how so much of American culture, theater, film is thriving in an aggressive and exciting way. And Brazilian cinema right now is absolutely in a golden age. Music is being exported everywhere.
I just wonder if looking back at the Socrates time, the 80s, where he had a similar thriving culture, I wonder if football is the final piece. And I'm just hoping that maybe the thriving elements of the other cultures, music and art and the rest of it, I'm hoping they can galvanize football too. And maybe, you know, some point in the near future, we will see major athletes, footballers, all the rest of them on stage alongside their siblings and other art forms, pushing the needle for democratic change. The professor has spoken.
Listen, let's jump back in that time machine, my friend. I love it. Let's do it. Our Copa is hosted by Merit Mathias, Musa Okwonga, and Julio Ricardo Varela.
Produced by Emma Foley and executive produced by Carrie Tolles and Clark Sonderman of TCBPR, with support from Working Families Power and Mijente Support Committee. featuring music by Pedazo de Carne Con Ojo and graphics by Caroline Speyer. for more information on how to organize around this year's world cup and to find an event near you visit www.ourcopa.com or at ourcopa26 on instagram
In the early 1980's, under military dictatorship, the Brazilian soccer team led by footballer Socrates created a microcosm of democracy that valued the opinions of all players and team management equally. The movement would cement Brazilian soccer as a breeding ground for political experimentation, idealism, and action.
Our Copa is hosted by Merritt Mathias, Musa Okwonga, and Julio Ricardo Varela
Produced by Emma Foley and executive produced by Carrie Tolles and Clarke Sondermann of TCB PR with support from Working Families Power and Mijente Support Committee.
featuring music by Pedazo De Carne Con Ojo and graphics by Caroline Spire
For more information on how to organize around this year’s World Cup and to find an event near you, visit www.ourcopa.com
Follow us on Instagram:
@ourcopa26
@okwonga
@julito77
@merrmerr9