Full time. Thanks for coming out. We’re back in the locker room drawing up new plays. Stay on the team sheet so you’re first to know when we take the field again.
Our Copa

← Follow Seguir

Podcast

Political Dissent and Economic Collapse at Mexico's 1986 World Cup

Episode · Jun 23, 2026 · 61 min

📄 Read the full transcript · Leer la transcripción

When I, you know, am looking and re-watching The Hand of God, Bowl, and all of these things, all I can think is what a perfect metaphor for the 1986 Mexico World Cup. Say more. You have this incredible act by Maradona in this moment, to Moose's point. It is inconceivable that you would even do something like this, but even in the moment you're like the athleticism the ability to time the ball the ability to risk going up against the goalkeeper coming out all these things and at the end of the day from far away you're like this is such a beautiful goal and I and I'm like oh from far away Mexico this world cup incredible they've been able to put this on they have the infrastructure I see what you're doing.

You zoom in. You zoom in on this goal, and it's actually the cheapest way to score. It's illegal in the game to use your hand. And you recognize that if you compare this back to Mexico, you have a government and a power completely cheating their people.

This is perfection. How are we going to talk? This is incredible. That's like a Maradona move.

that's a Maradona take on a Maradona move hello fellow time travelers I'm gonna host this one and I'm super excited do you mind if I tell why I'm super excited before because this is a very this is a very personal story for me so I'm gonna totally reveal my age and when I was born like I said I was born the year the New York Mets won the World Series. And man, you know, humans walked on the moon. You'll never say it again. Right?

The first time humans walked on the moon. So So I am a true Gen Xer. And I grew up as a teenager during the time of Ronald Reagan. During the time of the you know, the the roots of neoliberal neoliberalism.

And I'm originally coming. Yeah, I this is this is how I'm gonna set this up um I really appreciate you both in this one because I this is the episode I was so excited about when I was like what episode do you want to host Julio I'm like this one so because it's so personal to me so anyway imagine this I'm 16 years old in 1986 about to turn 17 during the 1986 world cup and the 1986 world cup took place in Mexico and I'm a kid from Puerto Rico. I was born in Puerto Rico. My parents got divorced when I was like seven or eight.

I, I was like, we, we shuttled back and forth between New York and Puerto Rico. But eventually, when my parents got divorced, I left Puerto Rico and lived in the Bronx with my mom. And, and, and then the second family, like my sisters and my stepdad and all that. So I have always felt proudly Puerto Rican and I've always dealt with like issues of identity like who where do I belong?

I really remember the 1986 World Cup in Mexico because all the games were broadcast in Spanish in the United States through the precursor to Univision. You know, everyone knows Univision and Telemundo, but it was a Spanish international network. And so they had all the games, all 52 games. And I knew enough about Mexico because I was inherently attached to Latin America and inherently attached to Latin America.

So because I'm from Puerto Rico. So I just started watching the games in Spanish in the Bronx at 16 and 17 years old. I had just gotten into Harvard undergrad, and I was like, things are good, and then I'm going to watch. Like, I have games.

I have World Cup games, which was very rare back in the United States back then. It wasn't, you know, I believe NBC was broadcasting them as well in English, but it wasn't, you know, it was 1986. It wasn't, you know, it wasn't when we were there. It's definitely like the precursor of interest in U.S.

audiences' interest in international soccer. So can you just imagine 16-year-old me, 17-year-old me, my birthday was during the World Cup. I'm a Gemini. Explains a lot, kids.

Explains a lot about me. But we get, you know, watching these games in Spanish in Mexico, seeing so many great teams, And then seeing this number 10 in a classic blue and white Celeste, you know, Argentina, this number 10, who to this day is not only a legend, an enigma, a human, right? This person named Maradona. I was, you know how Michael Jackson like to bring up like stars in the 80s, like they were big things.

It's like Maradona to me was a cultural like thunderbolt in my identity because I instantly saw my connection as someone who grew up in Puerto Rico, bilingual, bicultural, and seeing these South Americans, these Latin Americans performing. And he wasn't the only one, right? But seeing this greatness, and they were coming from this side of the continent in Mexico, where I felt like Puerto Rico and Mexico, I know Mexicans like in the Bronx back in the day. And so I was always attracted to Latin America to the point that after I went through the World Cup, when I finally got undergrad, I decided to study Latin American history and literature, Puerto Rican history and literature, Mexican history and literature, the Mexican Revolution.

Like, it shaped me. It shaped who I am as a journalist, as a sports fan. I was a sports writer for the Harvard Crimson back in the day. I love sports, and I've always loved sports and politics.

And the 1986 World Cup was like my origin story. So I appreciate you all for letting me explain that in the intro. How are you all doing? Good.

I'm so glad we got insight. One, I knew you were a Gemini. And two, to this core memory for you. It was, yeah.

So what, do you have any? I know Merit and, but did you have memories of the, of 86 Musa? I mean, I wasn't allowed to watch it. You weren't allowed to watch it?

No, because I was born in 1979 and it was just outside the window. I could stay up late because it was a different times. And in the case, I was not allowed to watch it. So I would get to school the next day and all my school friends who had been allowed to watch it would tell me what happened in the games.

So I listened to the entire 1986 World Cup through, I suppose, the floorboards because relatives who were old enough to watch it, watched it. So I didn't watch the 96 World Cup. It's this level of discipline as to why you are the professor you are today. I mean, you...

I'm locked in. I'm locked in now. I'm locked in. I mean, I thought I had a good story.

Like, you've taken... Wait, I want to hear more. So how did you feel? Like, how did you feel?

Were you into football? Was it something that you followed? Like, you loved it. You loved it.

Did you throw an absolute tantrum when you had to, like, go to bed knowing that the games were on? you have to understand that the early years me playing football was just shrouded in deception so my mum for years believed that one of my feet was like bigger than the other i didn't have the heart to tell her the reason was because my shoes like one side was always ruined right so i was running into the playground because one of my favorite footballers would drag his left he would drag his non-kicking foot before kicking with the other foot he would drag his foot like on the surface so i would do that so like one of my right my left foot was always like a fish mouth because i'd always drag it on on the concrete when playing in school and my mom was like oh my god your left side your left foot is always like open i said yeah yeah the left foot's bigger than the other so it was all deception so the i say all that to say the 86 world cup was something like what i reviewed at julius i read about it i heard about the myth so actually weirdly enough the myth that you're describing because i didn't watch in real time yeah the legend of maradona is all the greater because i heard about it you know like all the great bands when you hear about them it's more powerful when you hear about when you hear about nirvana and then you finally see them it's more mind-blowing because you've heard the hype so for me maradona was like being at the back of a crown looking at people's shoulders and then you hear all these people go oh my god this break dance is incredible and you finally get to the front and then you're like oh my god because you're already hyped so my experience of the world cup was kind of like it was almost like you telling me about it and then i finally see it because i was not allowed to watch it well musa i'm about to be you through this entire episode because i wasn't even a thought in 1986 i was not born until 1990 this i think i will have such different context and relatability to this moment like i will be you i'm listening through the floorboards it will be the two of you taking me through oh wow just for people that are listening um this episode like we mentioned is about the 1986 world Cup, specifically, like the Mexico, Mexico hosting it, and we're going to get into those things, even though, you know, we could talk about Maradona all day. But, you know, just to put it into context, we're in the same time period as the last episode, right? We were just in 1982, just, you know, with Socrates and the Corinthian democracy movement.

So we're just a few years ahead. And we're not that far away geographically, right? This is Latin America. We did talk about sort of how Brazil is sort of the lost part of Latin America in the previous episode.

But, you know, Mexico, definitely one of the top, you know, a very prominent country in Latin America. And we touched upon sort of the dictatorship and the economic crisis in the Brazilian episode with the Corinthian movement. And now we're looking at the effects of an economic crisis, the effects of an economic crisis on a civilian population in a one party system. And wait till I share like, Merit, you know, I know we have Professor Moussa, but I'm going to be like, you know, the assistant tutor today, because this is a story that I love to like, when you think about it, I'm going to ask you this question once we talk about who ruled Mexico back in 86.

But just put this in perspective. We are living in the 80s, neoliberalism, Reagan, Margaret Thatcher, technocrats. If you remember the Chicago School of Economics talking about every economic solution can be solved with – we can help capitalism better if we're more technocratic and as I do, a robot dance. I will say one thing before we get into this, because when I said what I said about 1986 Mexico and how it just was one of the inspirations for me to really study Latin American history and literature.

When I got to the elite space that school in Cambridge, you know, the Harvard undergrad, I actually met the sons and daughters of Mexican technocrats who were in the government. like you can imagine this kid from the Bronx in Puerto Rico and then you know you're you're talking Spanish you're like hey the Lundades where you from and all this and they're like oh I'm from Mexico City and I'm like whoa and I'm like what do you do it's like my dad's my dad's a government official and I'm like okay I would the fact that like that was also something that really impacted me. So let me ask you, the both of you, do you know when I say the Institutional Revolutionary Party, which is called the PRI, because it's Partido Revolucionario Institucional, did you know that they controlled Mexico for 71 consecutive years from 1929 to 2000 as the only de facto party. So Mexico was a one-party state.

Previous to, okay, this is where I'm going to get geeky. Previous to the Mexican Revolution, you know Emiliano Zapata and Pancho Villa and the sort of uprising of the workers against institutionalists in Mexico, the Mexican Revolution. So that all went, you know, once everything settled, what came out of that was an institutional revolutionary party that claimed to be an an onset you know um claimed to be sort of the uh originated from the mexican revolution when in fact it became an highly technocratic one-party system so just gonna show just gonna name two things here the two of you are like i had no when you say when you lost me when you rolling your r's i'm like technocratic can i just can i yeah technocratic because i'm i'm a little bit i got two please go for it all right i'm going to talk about two presidents right from mexico the first one is president jose lopez portillo okay and there's you know mexico has a lot of oil right and they just they just thought there's these these educated america They went to American business schools and American economic schools and other places around the world. This notion of capitalism – I wouldn't say it's fascist.

It's just like data-driven and if we're efficient and it's incredibly unequal. So Mexico made a lot of money with petroleum, right? I will say the Gulf of Mexico forever. As you should.

As I should, right? You know, there was a lot of – this was trying to push Mexico forward, right? Capitalism pushing Mexico forward. But in fact, you have an incredibly unequal system, and the PRI completely betrayed the Mexican Revolution.

So this notion of land reform and workers' struggle – and remember, this was happening during Russia. The Mexican Revolution was happening during the Russia movement and other movements that were for worker rights. But what happened was you created sort of this elite, educated, mostly white Mexican class that – I mean the wealth in Mexico, when you start seeing the people that have money in Mexico, it is the 1% of the 1% in the rest of the country. It struggles.

so imagine when you're doing all this and you're so dependent on oil and do i need to remind you what happened in the 70s right you know with the oil crisis yeah economic collapse a debt crisis so they're in trouble right and then because of that another dude who you know one party oh let's have an election there's only one party it's like it's not a dictatorship but you know so president miguel de la madrid and he ruled from 1982 through 1988 during the world cup and so because of this debt crisis all of a sudden he implements you know this is what technocrats do austerity measures and began shifting towards market-oriented economic policies and the privatization of state enterprises. Hate to hear it. Welcome to neoliberalism in Mexico. So that is the context, right?

Hate to hear it. So like we've seen this rodeo before and Mexico was all in, right? Just so you know, Mexico wasn't awarded the 1986 World Cup until 1983, which is – think about it. Think about – that wouldn't happen now if someone changes a venue.

Even Russia ran it. You know what I mean? Remember, they were in Russia and they didn't change venues. But in this specific case, FIFA was claiming that they needed more infrastructure improvements, and they thought that Colombia was, quote-unquote, too dangerous.

So Colombia, like once – Colombia was like, screw you. We're going to rescind. And I love my Colombian friends, so I'm like, I get it. They're like – because if there's one thing about Colombians, like they are so proud and love their country so much and they've been so misunderstood in the fact that it's like everyone thinks Colombia is this like drug country when in fact it's a beautiful country and beautiful people.

And I will let you know, they speak the best Spanish. Like I speak horrible bad bunny Spanish. Their Spanish accent when they speak in Spanish, I'm like, why is your Spanish so beautiful? as opposed to me with Puerto Ricans who are like, I can't even pronounce my ancestors.

Can I just say, for the record, I'm not co-signing this statement. I think it's a wonderful sentiment. Oh, that's right. They're going to come for me.

They're going to come. All right, good. Disclose. That's all me.

This is my opinion. Julio Ricardo Varela's opinion. Both Merit and Musa have disclosed. Yeah, I'm not co-signing this.

This is signed by JRV. And so I will own that. And if anyone, if other countries want to come after me, it's Julio at the Latino newsletter dot org. I do, however, love Bad Bunny Spanish.

I will live and die by some Bad Bunny Puerto Rican Spanish. That's all. Bad Bunny has made it cool to be Puerto Rican. So there you go.

So so back to Columbia, back to Columbia saying, like, we out of here, like we go, go FIFA. so do you all know remember here's one do you all remember henry kissinger yes henry kissinger's involved oh ta holio i have a question yes go okay you mentioned that mexico hits this like economic decline in the 70s because of the oil prices dropping they're in a form of a recession is that safe to say in the 70s? Yeah, it's like oil dependent, like state enterprises, things that people just you know, the price of oil, like it was a crash, right? I remember like Merit, there was a time Merit, when there were long gas lines in America in the 70s and you know we would have to go and wait two hours to fill our gas um you know i'm sorry it's like that was like me being like the older i remember like yeah you know what i mean it's like so it was during the grass crisis and so when you have these economies that are solely dependent on one or two commodities when the price you know when the price goes you know it's just it just causes collapse right yeah but so there's an economic collapse in mexico Yes, and there's like such inequality and you have this elite technocratic class and believe me, like I've seen them fly first class in planes.

I can pick out a technocratic rich Mexican any day. I'm really good at it. So if you ever need that, I can – that's sort of another skillet. Yeah, that's in my profile.

But back to Henry Kissinger, who was the former secretary of state. Total sarcasm here. Not controversial. Are you kidding me?

Like Henry Kissinger, when you look at the U.S. policy in the 70s and Vietnam and the bombing of Cambodia and just you want to talk about a cold technocrat. You know, this this sort of like real politic type of diplomat, which, you know, so so Colombia says, we're out of here. here and fifa calls up kissinger and says why doesn't the you know why can't we let's influence the u.s like give a call to reagan or someone or whoever whoever can help host the world cup maybe we host it in 1986 in the united states and i'm like like when i when i heard about that i was like yeah that wouldn't have happened right um but the fact that they fifa brought in the secretary of State, Henry Kissinger, to be like, yo, we got to find a venue.

And so they were, so the U.S., you know, so that didn't materialize. And then you know who else was a very public advocate for the U.S. hosting the World Cup in 1986? We talked about him.

We mentioned him in the Brazil episode. It's not Socrates. It's Pelé. So remember, Pelé was playing for the Cosmos.

he definitely had tapped into american like capitalism like it's like i always think about pele like in the cosmos you know living in the united states and pele was like i'm good i'm fine he was locked in yeah i was like this this capitalism like i like this so he was i'm benefiting yeah though yeah he's totally benefiting so so Pele was also involved now other fun fact about this and I haven't even begun to talk about um such other tragic events that happened in 1985 but I want to give it sort of I'm still sticking on the hosting of the cup struggle so FIFA's like oh we don't have the U.S. I mean you know Pele is talking I'm sure there's people in 1983 in the United States. It's like, who's Pelé? Like, that was also that.

So America wasn't ready for soccer tournament in 1986. And I think they were ready in 92. But, you know, in 86, I don't think they were there. So Mexico, in 1970, hosted the World Cup, right?

And wasn't that, Moussa, was that, Brazil won that one, in 1970 or? Yeah, Brazil, and they did a great job, yeah, by all accounts. Right, and there's the iconic image of Pelé, Like that was a great World Cup for Brazil. But, you know, they became the first country to host the World Cup twice.

So Mexico had hosted the World Cup in 1970, and 16 years later they were going to host the World Cup in 1986, which, you know, we're talking about FIFA here. That was a little bit controversial. And this is what I love about FIFA. there's always claims that you know there were political alliances so you remember joao havalange right joao the fifa president the legendary fifa president um there's always these claims that and they're never fully proven but always with fifa it's like well those are just rumors you know the president joao havalange he favored mexico due to political alliances and commercial interests over fairness.

So this is where it comes. This is like one party rule, right? So FIFA's like, he's like, oh, I'm connected to Mexico. They hosted the World Cup in 1970.

It was a pretty, you know, and if we recall, that happened just like two years, 1968 was a student protest. There was a lot of violence in Mexico. And that was the year of the Olympics with the Black Power Fist that happened in Mexico City. But there were protests.

There was violence. There was repression happening. And the PRI, the one-party rule of Mexico, they were oppressing their people. So going into 1970, it wasn't a great situation either for Mexico.

And the other thing that Mexico had for the 1986 World Cup was this incredibly strong broadcasting infrastructure known as Televisa, right? Which had powerful ties to FIFA. And basically, for lack of a better word, Televisa is like state-run, one-party television in Mexico. Like they were the broadcasting...

Is it Fox News? that's it that's it like it has like fox like it it's it's kind of like it's i don't think it's calmer but it was more like pretending to be unbiased but when you're in a one-party system who are you being biased against more like yes yeah but it's like yeah like like yeah like if If you have direct relationships with the government, with the PRI, and they're like, you know, the Mexican government reported today. As a journalist, it's like you're just spouting propaganda, right? There's no challenges here.

So Televisa was this friendly partner. Little side note, Televisa also now owns Univision in the United States. Oh, wow. So and the fact that Televisa was close to the United States, that was also important for like the border areas because people could get Televisa in.

Because as we remind people, Mexico, you know, that part of the United States was part of Mexico after the Mexican, you know, before the Mexican-American War. This notion of the we didn't cross the border, the border crossed us like there's a lot of Mexican-American families that will tell you like we've been here for generations. So having Televisa was making it a financially attractive choice in some of the lower U.S. markets.

And then you had the growing Latino population, Spanish-speaking population in the United States. So to get 52 broadcasts, Spanish-language broadcasts in 1986 in the U.S. market goes back to teenager Julio Ricardo Varela. I was one of many who was enthralled by the fact that these games were being broadcast in Spanish.

and hands down let's just be real like watching a game with spanish language broadcasters is so much better than like no disrespect for the queens or the kings english or like you know but you could watch a spanish language broadcast of a soccer game the greatest words about soccer not being spoken in english that's pretty clear that's absolutely the case yes they may not even i mean yeah yeah they're not being spoken within an ocean of me so you're totally right man all All right, so I'm going to pause because I gave the context just on the World Cup. I haven't even gotten into the politics of Mexico at this time, and I wanted to just like throw it out to my fellow time travelers about thoughts about the 1986 World Cup and the context and how they were looking for a new host. And Henry Kissinger was involved. Like there's a lot here.

So Merritt, you wanted to learn. Do you have any thoughts about it? I did want to learn. To kind of follow up on my first question, just gaining understanding around this economic collapse that you saw in the 70s within Mexico.

And then you mentioned Colombia potentially hosting this 1986 World Cup. And while it was perceived to be dangerous and all these things, there was a need from FIFA at the time to have an investment in infrastructure. And my question is, is when Mexico was given the nod in 1983, that they would be hosting this 1986 World Cup, were they in a better place than Colombia in terms of infrastructure or the ability to invest? Oh, that's a great question.

This is the perfect transition. So So Mexico, the 1980s in Mexico, they're often referred to as the country's lost decade, right? Because there was such stagnation of – there wasn't a lot of economic growth and there was a plummeting GDP, right? And there was this massive debt crisis in 1982, which led to severe inflation and a steep decline in living standards.

And like think about this, right? Like if you can't pay for services, you're going to borrow, right? So you have all these like economic – these elite economic – whatever the school was, the University of Chicago, that type of – We are going to finance government, blah, blah, blah. And so this is super simple.

Like if you don't have the money to pay for your debt, guess what? Shit happens, right? Like I just try to break it down because sometimes economic reporting – you know like ever notice, Musa, that economic reporting? They try to make it super difficult.

And like I love the fact that Merit is asking like, so what actually happened? basically they couldn't pay for their bills like let's just put this in a budget perspective like you know i can't pay for rent i can't pay for food i can't like it's people like we overthink the the economic disparity in the debt crisis right musa like i feel like they purposely i think like capitalists purposely want to make it difficult and inaccessible to talk about the economy when in fact this is very simple it's like can can can you and can the government ensure that people are housed and fed and taken care of and have access to health care and and like can pay for it without inflation and the over you know overvaluing of the peso there was these jokes that like a dollar in mexico would be like you know thousands of pesos in the 80s i mean do you want to jump in on just economic like failure and like technocratics yeah the first thing i've ever read about economics to help me understand it's a very very thin book um i think it's called the doctrine of innocent fraud by jk galbraith and it was basically like as i remember it was like here's the thing about like markets being fair they're not fair because most people haven't got time to read up on the markets or read the rules it's the people who have an advantage or the people who have time to sit around who don't have like a partner and a couple of kids who don't have three jobs and they actually have time to sit and wait for the best stock to become available and by the time the best stock is sold like by the time like you've come back from work from your one of your three jobs that day all the best stock is sold and you have no info about it so the markets are completely unfair and the moment i started looking at the economics that way just to come back to you you know there's there's a youtube video of like a cat where they're hiding a piece of food you know like when you're shuffling like the cups and they put the food under one of the three cups and they shuffle it around and they're like can the cat find it the cat is like yeah i the cat always finds it it's really funny ever since i saw that video i was like that's economics it's like you're just you're just shuffling cups so i can't find the food but actually it's if i look hard enough yeah yeah i'll find out or if you're the cat and able to watch the maneuvering of the cup you'll likely pick the cup exactly it speaks to this idea that economics is so rooted in, like, if your basic needs are not met, if you cannot clothe yourself, if you cannot find sufficient food, if you are struggling with a roof over your head, the likely step is that you have no ability or space, to your point, Musa, to watch the stock market, to be able to invest in financial security. So it sounds like in Mexico, the majority of Mexican sorry the majority of Mexicans are not their basic needs are not being met which means and it's a one party rule it's a one party rule you have these technocrats and I'm going to go a little bit deeper on the origins of neoliberalism Milton Friedman the economist who taught econ 101 it was required it was required for like economic students so neoliberalism was seen as sort of the the solution and it had its roots in the 50s and it went all the way and you have i mean you have these mexican students who are studying in american schools who are like this is the way right and the reality is when you're dealing with a one-party system corruption you're only taking care of the people like who do you take care of right people in the one party so you're like I'm a big pre-supporter. And it's like, okay, you're good.

Here's your little cushy little political job. But at the same time and talking about Mexico's lost decade of the 80s, what happens? When you're in a debt crisis, when you have austerity measures, when services aren't provided, poverty skyrockets because you're not investing in social programs, infrastructure, healthcare, and education. It's only for the wealthy few.

And again, like the peso, which is the Mexican currency, was ridiculously – it was silly how much it – how much – it had no value. It was so devalued. So from that happened, that happened in 1982. But then in 1985, massive tragedy happens in Mexico.

Devastating earthquake. Devastating. Eight months, eight months before the start of the 1986 World Cup. So it killed thousands of people.

It still is. It's one of Mexico's, in modern day Mexico, it's probably on the same level of, to give it other tragedies, just natural disasters. I'm from Puerto Rico. When people say Hurricane Maria, I get chills.

So when you talk about the 1985 Mexico City, you know, Mexico earthquake, people in that generation remember it. And, you know, those are, again, those are people that were teenagers like me, who are now in their 50s. So think about that, right? And we're going to host a World Cup.

then i just gave some more details and i want to hear what y'all think about that moment in terms of like how do technocrats deal with natural disasters and climate change and all that but the administration the pre-administration like initially refused foreign aid they acted slowly oh my god they covered up the death toll what a surprise uh one part we don't want to look bad they prioritize the country's image over rescue and this is related to the world cup they're like oh we got a world cup in eight months like oh yeah we have thousands of mexicans dead i'm like but we got to worry about the world cup right there's a continued lack of public services and it's just going to get more intensified and intensified and a lot of citizens who were kind of like i'm done you know who were kind of like what we talked about in brazil like this doesn't impact me i'm apolitical they were starting to get drawn towards activism and experience a political awakening and after the 1985 earthquake the government's continued support and resources the event like the actual like the world cup engendered like people were just pissed amongst civilians who were barely surviving there's like why do we have a world cup happening so musa and then merit like i've given you sort of the context because there are two different mexicos here there's the elite when you describe the technocratic state it's funny because when you describe the the actions as opposed to the word i think to myself it just sounds like polite authoritarianism yeah the technocrat yes yeah it just sounds like because even like the techniques of like national prestige and projection of soft power like to me the question keeps coming back to me is like they're not they don't have the infrastructure necessarily for it they're coming from tragedy what is this really about and it almost feels like it feels like fascism with well not fascist it feels like authoritarianism with a suit and tie oh does that make sense oh yeah and maybe a clip maybe a clipboard oh yes you i love this this class is good merit what are your thoughts when i because like what this is what's happened this is what happened in mexico in 85 and 86 it's like there's two different mexicos at this time right there's this nation literally covered in rubble you know they're defined by suffering this earthquake was monumental and then they have this like the technocrats would be like oh we have a world cup we have an international stage and we're gonna project you know we're gonna project unity and recovery from disaster we're gonna use the world cup to say like things are going great here what do you think about that play yeah there's so much here i i you know i think the middle class often just reaps incredible devastation throughout history. And when you see a decimation of a middle class, which you've likely seen in Mexico from an economic crisis to a natural disaster, a lack of a middle class only empowers the uber rich or the uber powerful within that country. That is my point of view. So I look at Mexico and I guess from under, you know, wrapping my head around what this time for Mexico looks like.

And a very angry middle class. A very just... Very little too. Like the middle class is very small in Mexico.

So I think it's like angry classes. Yeah. You have like a more polarized... Yeah, the guys with the clipboards.

Yeah, you have a very polarized Mexico at this point. Right. Which often just sets the stage for rebellion, correct? Oh, yeah.

You were getting ahead of the story, but this is good. Okay, I'm not going to jump there, but I'm just kind of trying to get my feet rooted. You are absolutely 100% correct. And guess what?

Soccer plays a role in the future of Mexico after this. As it should. Musa, before we get into— Wait, I have one more thing to ask. Go ahead.

I just want to finish my thought. So you have this polarized country. You have this World Cup planned to come to Mexico. Is the messaging to the public at that time to kind of soften this investment into the World Cup and this likely investment they are going to have to have in infrastructure due to a natural disaster and the history of Mexico?

Is this messaging to the public more of this World Cup will bring in income that will help build up a rubble of Mexico? Like, how was this messaging to the public happening from the very elite? Excellent question, because remember what I said about Televisa as sort of being the state-run network of the PRI, the one party that ruled Mexico for 71 years. What, you know, mass media, mass entertainment, they were just like, nothing to see here.

Like, let's just, you know, we got a World Cup. Like, they weren't really raising any awareness. and and so i does it does speak to some of the themes that we've talked to in the past when you're living in undemocratic societies so that we expand authoritarianism and you know the techno technocratic world not to get but there's a lot of people that just tune out if you're not you know they tune out right and so that was clear um but musa but the 1986 cup does happen and it was the site of perhaps one of the most iconic moments in world football yeah this is the wild thing you know it's funny because you're talking about i'm trying to draw some parallels between a state which is kind of a polite authoritarian state mexico and a kind of more explicit authoritarian state argentina who've won the world cup in 78 and now have this like iconic maradona right and to your point about it being a great world cup maradona claims the world cup with argentina spoiler for those listeners but also along the way defeats defeats england right in this incredible so you want to talk more about that game because it's called the hand of god game and did you listen did you listen through through the floorboards or do you know what i think i saw this reported i don't think i watched so it was this huge game so england play argentina the quarterfinal of the world cup england have not won the world cup for 20 years um their first and only victory coming in 66 argentina have won it like eight years ago and maradona is seen as the next great maybe the greatest argentina player of all time right yeah and so what happens in this game is that argentina take the lead through um a goal by maradona which he ends up scoring with his hand you couldn't get away today because of video replays but he goes up to head the ball the ball gets passed through and the goalkeeper comes out and as he's going to head the ball maradona puts his it's actually quite clever what he does yeah right it's wild isn't it he puts his he puts his fist yeah his raised fist up next to his head and use it to punch the ball over the goalkeeper into the unguarded net and the clever thing about that both of you is if you think about the context of football right the fact that like you play this game with your head your shoulders like every other part of your body but your hand it's so unnatural in that moment to even consider using your hand and the risk is so severe because the referee could see you and send you off like if you think of the risk it's still nil nil right he's the best player on the pitch best player in the tournament he's already playing very well in the opening you know games i think he scored against italy a beautiful goal so maradona is like all the hope is on this guy yeah and isn't it interesting that he chooses his hand because we'd never seen somebody at that stage of a tournament like a pro follower even attempt something like this that means so and it's yeah i want to hear i want to hear yeah because it's Because it's so out there as a thing, they end up calling it the hand of, well, he calls it the hand of God. He calls it the hand of God, right?

Yeah, because it's such a like wild, ridiculous thing. And the name sticks. Both of you lived through this World Cup, correct? Like you have just such- I watched it.

He listened through it on the floorboards and talked to his mates. Yes, the answer is yes. You lived this experience, right? I did not.

And so when I am looking and re-watching The Hand of God, Goal, and all of these things, all I can think is, what a perfect metaphor for the 1986 Mexico World Cup. Wow. Say more. Let me get my thoughts.

But this is what I see when I see this, because I don't have this cultural moment. This goal does not sit in my world the same way Brandi Chastain's PK goal sits for me. That was my hand-in-glove moment. Yep.

Right. So for me, you're watching this, and I'm like, you have this incredible act by Maradona in this moment. To Moose's point, it is inconceivable that you would even do something like this. But even in the moment, you're like the athleticism, the ability to time the ball, the ability to risk going up against the goalkeeper coming out, all of these things.

And at the end of the day, from far away, you're like, this is such a beautiful goal. And I'm like, oh, from far away, Mexico, this World Cup, incredible. They've been able to put this on. They have the infrastructure.

I see what you're doing. You zoom in. You zoom in on this goal. and it's actually the cheapest way to score.

It's illegal in the game to use your hand. And you recognize that if you compare this back to Mexico, you have a government and a power completely cheating their people. This is perfection. How are we going to plot?

This is incredible. That's like a Maradona move. That's a Maradona take on a Maradona move. Yeah, I just 360 your ass.

Yeah, that is on the same level as Maradona. And I have never, I mean, I've been obsessed with this play. I've been obsessed also with his run where he just made the English defenders look silly. Yeah, it's insane.

Like, I watch it. I'm like, how the hell does he do this? But it's super interesting you say this because whatever it was, right, the greatness of Maradona in Mexico in 1986 was very special. Like the impact of what that tournament did, not only for his statue, but just for his legend.

And I can imagine the people left out in Mexico who probably saw this tournament as like, I'm not getting anything in return, but I get to witness greatness. Yes. Right. And maybe soccer gives you hope because, I mean, there wasn't any Socrates that happened post 86 in Mexico where there was, you know, change happened slowly.

But one of the things that happened post World Cup to and to get to your point, Merit, about like, yes, it did feel cheap. Right. And guess what? There was anger.

And guess what? This was the beginning of the end of the pre. Like it took a long time, right? But in 1988, there was this huge split in the PRI.

And it was Cuauhtémoc. I always mispronounce his name. So it was like, I think it's like Cuauhtémoc Cárdenas. I know it's Cárdenas.

His name is indigenous, the first name. But that split led to a weakening of the party's absolute control and saw the rise of competitive left-wing opposition. So what you're seeing, so even the seeds of change during this quote-unquote, I'm going to say like the cheap World Cup, it looked pretty from the outside, but when you really look at it, it was cheap, and it was, you know, it's like you cheated, bro. You cheated.

I love what Merritt says, because there's something about what Merritt said about the perfect metaphor. This is incredible. Yeah. There's something about like capitalism, right?

like you're brought up in the capitalist system to be like it's fair the markets work efficiently and it's almost like maradona's two goals the two faces of that the one face is like oh my god look it's just because of your beautiful individual excellence that you achieve and you can strive and you're the best and the flip side of it is its true face which is like actually it's when it takes all doesn't matter how you achieve it because people if you if you look at like everyone on the victor's podium nobody remembers an asterisk like there is no winning medal even like you know the guy that won what seven seven tour de france like lance armstrong everyone can talk about the asterisk behind those but ultimately he got to taste the glory he still felt you can take away all the trophies you like but mary you know how it is as an athlete as an athlete the moment of lifting the trophy is something that you remember beyond anything and no one can take that no one can literally rescind that and i feel like this is something about the lost decade right there's something about the stolen there's a parallel to merit's point the stolen futures the stolen decade and the stolen trophy it's kind of the two kind of like they kind of like it i like it and again listen that's why we're time travelers that's why we're yeah this is this is like i was like i'm telling the story and then it's like i got you but like but but but the point being like just before we wrap up because there is hope to all this there is a hopeful end one of them being that the end of the PRI was beginning, right? What I said with Cárdenas, where you start seeing, like if you look at Mexico now, there is more healthier political competition. There's still a lot of inequality. They are an interesting neighbor in the time of the second Trump administration and Scheinbaum, the first president of Mexico, first woman president of Mexico, like she doesn't put up with DJTs like bullshit.

Like she's one of the first people who like calls them out. And people know that Mexico and the United States are very interconnected and they've always been. But this notion of the anger that happened in the last decade and how, yeah, Maradona cheated, but like he's still Maradona. like that legend was there and so change is not easy there's a lot of complexity nobody is perfect and i'm not defending it believe me married like any central back of that you know if that happened and i'm like we're the english let's go fight this guy right you know like let's mix it up like you just did something like incredibly like you cheated and i was like look get the brawl let's go let's fight right i have a question yeah on because this was televised you know this moment is televised this tournament is televised i'm curious if the broadcasting did its job in the way that it was you know this partnership was intended to do that there wasn't this ability to really complicate moments like this because what was being served to the general public viewing through TV was this is an iconic moment.

Mexico is in a great place. This world cup is the best thing that's happened to Mexico. Look at this natural disaster where a country that's going to be able to put this on. So I just, I'm so curious of what that messaging was and was there a miss and that messaging that would have maybe altered your feeling towards these moments in the way it was held.

Now I'm going to be like, I don't know what the floorboards told you, Musa, but from what I recall, all I remembered was, wow, Maradona, like he showed up against England and he became a legend. So at least from the Spanish language broadcast, I don't think there was a lot of – it was kind of like when he said hand of god at least this is from what i can remember so you know i was i mean i'm also this is 1986 this is uh you know this is 40 years ago so i'm like i don't and i also was a different time right it wasn't like hot takes and algorithms and it's like he's cheating or he's not cheating you know like that's what we live in like this was like analog the only thing you really had was like broadcast television maybe radio and print um i don't recall at least from my perspective 1986 will always be maradona's like world cup triumph yes that was right can i say actually can i go for it you know i love that just and i'll be very quick i think with what maradona did in that world cup right the fact that he scored a second goal that was that mind-blowing i quite like that he did that because then it wasn't just the goal the game was decided by that the game was decided ultimately by his genius and there's a lot of conversation about this convent there's this this performance because this arguably was not even his best before it's the tournament because in the next game they play against belgium and he scores twice in the semi-final and he scores an incredible goal in that match which i think is even better because in the second in the semi-final everybody knows he's coming everyone knows so it's like it's like a it's like john wick when everyone knows that like john wick's coming for that one guy it's like it's like and there are like all the security are lined up waiting to stop him and he still perseveres so in a way i think like maradona's genius now his legend actually begins his global legend actually begins i think in the quarterfinal and then by the time you get to the final against west germany when it's two two with like 10 minutes to go and everyone in the world knows that maradona's going to get the ball but everyone is marking him closely he still finds the impossible pass to create the final goal like it's there's a very good for those who haven't checked it out there's an amazing 10 minutes short on the fifa youtube where it's the last 10 minutes of the world cup final and it's like everyone was watching maradona everyone was marking him but we knew there's an amazing quote one of his teammates saying we knew his left foot was going to give us something yeah yeah and the past that he creates yeah it's that i don't know if i feel like you speak of maradona and and this time in mexico which was you know troublesome for the population but i also it kind of reminds me of Qatar in 2022, where there's so much protest leading in for the slave labor that was used to build these stadiums. And, and then you have this World Cup final, and you have Messi, and you have this incredible battle between him and Mbappe, and Messi is able to get his, like, his, you know, elusive World Cup trophy. And I guess I guess I can understand from that perspective, how all the tragedy that led up or all the protests or all the discomfort that led into hosting a World Cup in these countries, that these defining sports moments can almost erase it from your memory.

You can kind of disassociate from how this country had treated their people leading up to the World Cup, how they lied to them, how they've, you know, exploited this population or, you know, exploited the people of their country. So I'm like, oh, I understand how the Maradona moment can live on and be bigger than what was happening in Mexico. Yeah. And perfect, perfect insight to sort of bring this all together, because you're absolutely right, Merit.

OK, first of all, I don't think you were born in 19 because you've, you've, you've done some, I think you were there in spirit in 1986 because the two insights, the insights that you have given about this world cup, I'm sitting here going, yeah, that was, that was that. Yep. And you just did it again. But those, so remember there was an angry populace and there were protests happening in Mexico in 86 and exactly what happened.

And a lot of these foreign journalists who were like, oh, Mexico is technocratic. It's like neoliberalism. They weren't aware of anything, right? So they started covering the crisis in Mexico.

There was more international coverage because of this World Cup in the sense of like, wait a minute. This is what's going on here. And that also played into the change of the PRI sort of beginning to disintegrate. So I still – even though you weren't there or part of this world, the physical world, Merit, I think you were there.

Spiritually, you were there. You were probably like, oh, I see the facade here, y'all. Like little – Merit, I see what's happening and the fact that you make those connections. But that's the hope.

So I'm just going to toss it to the two of you to get any final thoughts on this story, this time traveling story. Like we covered a lot. Can I just say a quick thought? It's very, very short.

Hopefully not even more than two sentences. It feels like have faith that the work in progress is going to be worth it because I'm sure there's a lot of activists doing work during the World Cup going, this is all in vain. but actually as it turned out maybe a parallel with the socrates episode the work that you do because it takes place over such a long scale actually you're going to feel futile in the short term but in the long term this stuff can come good i feel like i take that from it yeah married i mean spiritually you were there so spiritually physically especially spiritually i was there physically i'm here um yeah i i just keep being reminded through all these episodes just the importance of the middle class and how important it is for that for the for the majority that we typically see in countries to be taken care of and when they aren't the explosive nature of power and corruption that can take place. And I will not go on, I will not go into my whole spiel of how Mexico of 1986 replicates kind of what we're seeing within the United States in terms of we have money for infrastructure or to build a ballroom, but we don't have money to keep people on Medicare and Medicaid.

And I just continuously think, I mean, shout out Mamdani of just the understanding and the crucial aspect of the middle class, not only for the health of a country, but for the ability for sport to remain true and pure. That is the majority of the people of the country. That is the majority of the people that will enter into the stadium and pay their hard-earned money to watch greatness. Viva Mexico.

That's all I'm going to say. Viva Mexico. Long live Mexico. Thank you, fellow soccer, football, time travelers.

we are leaving Mexico. Adios. Nos vemos. Cuídense todos.

And we'll see you at the next episode. Peace. Our Copa is hosted by Merit Mathias, Musa Okwonga, and Julio Ricardo Varela. Produced by Emma Foley and executive produced by Carrie Toles and Clark Sonderman of TCBPR with support from Working Families Power and Mijente Support Committee.

featuring music by pedazo de carne con ojo and graphics by caroline spire for more information on how to organize around this year's world cup and to find an event near you visit www.ourcopa.com or at our copa 26 on instagram

Episode notes · Notas del episodio

In 1986, on the heels of an economic crisis and an earthquake that severely disrupted Mexican infrastructure and civilian life, the country moved forward as hosts of the 13th FIFA World Cup, an event defined by the friction between celebration of a sport foundational to the Mexican identity and a period of intense regional strife.

Credits · Créditos

Our Copa is hosted by Merritt Mathias, Musa Okwonga, and Julio Ricardo Varela
Produced by Emma Foley and executive produced by Carrie Tolles and Clarke Sondermann of TCB PR with support from Working Families Power and Mijente Support Committee.
featuring music by Pedazo De Carne Con Ojo and graphics by Caroline Spire
For more information on how to organize around this year’s World Cup and to find an event near you, visit www.ourcopa.com
Follow us on Instagram:
@ourcopa26
@okwonga
@julito77
@merrmerr9