Full time. Thanks for coming out. We’re back in the locker room drawing up new plays. Stay on the team sheet so you’re first to know when we take the field again.
Our Copa

← Follow Seguir

Podcast

How Mussolini Turned the World Cup Into Propaganda

Episode · Jun 2, 2026 · 57 min

📄 Read the full transcript · Leer la transcripción

We mentioned it before, Uruguay boycotted, right? There's an argument that actually by doing that, they played the long game. They preserved their power and their aura because they won the World Cup in 1950. And they're still now the team that nobody really wants to play, even though they're playing badly at the World Cup.

I love the fact that every time you bring up, you have this knack in this time travel that you just ground us in the football, in the results. You have become our encyclopedic World Cup. Like, I need to remind you that Uruguay held out. They boycotted.

There was solidarity with other, like, South American countries. And then they played the long game and won again in 1950. That's resistance. I think it's identity.

You know what it is, Julio? I think someone once said that memory is resistance, right? And I think the idea that you stand for your ideals no matter what happens. You had, like, was it Senegal at the recent?

For those who didn't get a chance to watch it, Senegal in the recent African Cup of Nations, they basically walked off the pitch right in protest at a decision for morocco in the recent african cup of nations final and some would criticize their decision to walk off but actually there's something quite powerful about saying that the outcome of a sporting fixture is not the most important thing about the fixture i'm julio regalo varela journalist non-profit leader advocate for free speech massive arsenal supporter. I love the US men's soccer team, even though I'm Puerto Rican, which is very complicated. And I still play football in my Gen X generation. So hi, I'm excited.

Hi, my name is Misukwonga. I'm based in Berlin. I am a writer and co-host of the Stadio Football Podcast. Huge football fan ever since I could walk and a bit before that too.

And yeah, just love talking about football and all the ways it affects us, good and the bad. um hi i'm mary matthias i am a former professional athlete i spent 12 years of my career in the nwsl i have since retired i am now an nwsl broadcast analyst and once in a while i bop into a little podcasting i was drawn to this project because i thought for a long time about the relationship between football and social justice and wider political issues but the thing is the more i look the more I realize how little I actually know about it. So even looking at some of the conversations to have with the work I'm approaching, I'm like, my goodness, there's an entire backstory history to this stuff that I just don't know. So actually I'm a little bit nervous because there's just a ton of things I'm ignorant about.

So I'm trying to educate myself in the process of this. So I guess I was hoping to like learn on the job. That's why I'm here. I think that was like very honest because I'm sure there's people that are listening who are probably asking the same questions.

And I fall in the same boat, although I was drawn to this project because I've always been obsessed with sports and politics and how power uses and manipulates sports and nationalism. And, you know, we're all in this together to win. And the last senior paper that I wrote in college, and this was like two weeks before I graduated, which I'm like, who's doing a 35 page paper on the Argentine 1978 World Cup, you know, where the Argentinian dictatorship was, you know, was literally manipulating the tournament for Argentina to win. And I'm going to totally reveal my age.

This was pre-internet. This was like landlines. This was like typewriters. Computers were just starting to come into the college campus.

So this was in 1989, 1990. And I just went down the rabbit hole of this one story. And I was like, the fix was in. Imagine if this happened during the time of social media, the time of digital media and the time of disinformation and propaganda that we're all kind of living in the time of like algorithms taking over our feeds.

So once I heard about the project, I'm like, oh, this makes total sense. And also, I'm one of those stupid individuals that still plays the game in my, you know, for like, I'm still playing. It's stupid. I know.

Says the professional footballer. And I'm like, why am I still playing? You're not the only person who says that, Merit. I'm sure your wife.

But I will say with all the conversations that we've had about that, it gives me joy. I look forward to playing on the weekends, whether it's 7v7. And I don't know how I still play on a large pitch, but I do. and so I've always seen the sport as a place of joy a place where you can you know it's just such a human it's the most human sport like I believe in the world we just live live with it you know we get anxious about it and then when you get that goal like I know it sounds really stereotypical but I mean when your team scores when they have to score is one of the greatest feelings as a sports fan.

And I and I believe in that joy. But at the same time, I'm like, why do people have to mess with that? Why does power have to mess with that? So you know, I feel like this this show will try to explore that tension a little bit.

But I'm also super excited that you know, I live in the Boston area. I'm, I'm half an hour from Gillette Stadium, or what they call Boston Stadium during the tournament where the games are being held. And I'm still trying to get into a World Cup game. I'll figure it out.

But I don't know. It's just a lot, as you can tell. Yeah, holy, I think you touched on something there saying that it's probably the most human experience we have in sport. And I think that's because there's such fluidity to the game.

There's not this ability to call a timeout set a play. There is the ability to, you know, scout teams and hope for the best that your game plan is going to work out and you can execute against that game plan and hopefully go on to win, you know, the respected match. But no other sport looks like this. It's 45 minutes where you as a player have complete control over what is going to happen when the ball is at your foot or not at your foot.

And it mimics life in such a way that I don't believe other sport does. So many other sports have the ability to kind of in the moment, stop the play or look very similar over and over again. You know, when the quarterback's dropping back and rotates to the right, it's probably going to the wide receiver and you can study that film over and over again. Soccer player, you're like, I have an idea of what this attacker might do, but that's not a definitive thing.

And I, I feel a soccer has a draw for power because people feel so much when they watch it and you know the game and when become a student of the game it's it can elicit so much emotion just like everything else but it's a global game it is it holds weight everywhere and if you can start to control the messaging through soccer the idea is that you can potentially control the masses that watch it and inevitably controlling soccer is like controlling life and i think over and over again soccer just continues to fight against power that's so well musa that's deep that's the best articulation of that i'm like this is how we're starting the series because that is can i just say exactly i'm going to say that's the best articulation merit with my two favorite contributions so far not only that but also the two-footed tackle on julio's footballing career no i'm here for it i'm here for it i will i will contribute but for now i'm just eating popcorn hey you know merit i i'm a moussa please come in because i i i know it sounds really trite soccer is life i i feel like there are other sports that are can be frustrating but there's not many sports it's probably the only sport that i know that like anything can happen at any moment and you're just constantly like what decision do i make like you're just my favorite yeah well it's one of my favorite books by a guy called um renus mickles the um the great dutch coach in the 70s and he had this thing about like he wrote this amazing book called team building it's quite hard to find and i basically took me months to get it online but i got a copy in the end and he was talking about the reason my football was so addictive and so alluring and it's that like you have the highest number of combinations of individual interactions like you know it's like 11 players times 10 times 9 times 8 times 7 times 6 like it's just the number of combinations of interactions and the opportunity for randomness and if you look and Merrick rightly points out a lot of other sports seem concerned with almost like doing life the right way so it's like okay in you can't regulate life but you can regulate you look something golf for example you know from putt to putt um from shot to shot you can stop regroup regulate but the thing i love about football is that rather like life the decisions you make at the very beginning of a game can affect the outcome at the end and a choice that you make you look at like for example the paris saint-germain men's team right when they kick off they kick and they give the ball away like what an act of confidence that is that is like it's like announcing when at the start of it's like announcing your first week at university i'm going to finish top of like the entire university it's like such a bold statement you're not meant to do that in life like yeah and football is just go out there and do it in a game so random like you can't guarantee an outcome right and you look at basketball where you have like a victor wimbernyama or i don't know a lebron james and they can pretty much say i'm going to score x points tonight i'm going to take it over like you cannot you can't yeah what messi did in the last world cup was so incredible because Leo Messi took over what six out of seven matches when he chose to like to impose yourself and this is the fascinating thing about football for me is that the ability of individuals to impose themselves on to impose order on chaos on an essentially chaotic thing that is fascinating and I think watching that as a human being watching that is inherently exciting because you're like there's no way you're going to do that it's like watching someone rollerblade between the two towers right like it's like that level of artistry so yeah that's why i find it compelling i love the what you just said it's it's to impose order on chaos is such i mean just but isn't that what and i think that to get to like the crux of the this series this and so what you just said and i agree with you meredith i'm i'm i wish i'm writing these things down isn't that what power is trying to do as well or they think that they can impose order on like let's use soccer to impose our order but because the sport has that ability to be so creative and and and sort of unpredictable be careful what you wish for right be care if you're going to try to impose order on this sport something is going to fight against it whether it's on the pitch whether it's in the stands, whether it's, you know, when we talk about the World Cup, like, who knows, when we talk about what's going to be happening in the United States, and in Mexico, and in Canada over the next, you know, month in the summer, we don't even know where this is going to go. When you have an admit, you know, here I am, I'm going to just totally play like, hi, I live in the United States of America in 2026. Like, this is like, looking at the past of what like looking at these examples of power trying to control the world cup we are going to see it during the 250th anniversary of the united states like all the factors of america are being sort of clashing in this tournament and i still think that there's going to be this these moments of resistance where you know people talk about the high ticket prices people talking about the fact that I'm not going to the United States. Are you kidding me?

Like I'm coming from, like there was an example. Remember when Iraq had made it? They were one of the teams that was qualifying. And I remember seeing this video of Iraqi fans in Houston, Texas.

I think they were going to Mexico to catch Iraq play. And they were being vilified for just supporting their national team in a World Cup qualifying match. And those are the things that I want, looking back at history to see where we are in this moment. I will say also, like, I'd rather like celebrate in Canada and Mexico than in the United States.

It's going to be interesting. I just think it's going to be interesting to see how propagandistic it's going to be in the context of this current administration and how it's going to be America. I mean, I need to remind everyone, it's the World Cup is going to be happening during the 250th celebration in the United States, to the Declaration of Independence during July 4th. And the U.S.

national team, I don't think they're going to like advance. So there's going to be a lot of like factors here. Look, first of all, it's an interesting time for all the three hosts, right? Obviously Mexico have been through a lot and it's difficult quite to gauge what their relationship is with.

It's so strange because the current U.S. administration is both antagonistic towards elements of the Mexican government and also supportive. And then you've got Canada And it's almost like the siblings that have never really fought on that scale who are suddenly at each other's necks. Well, it's a kind of a one-sided feud.

It's a bit like an emcee picking a beef with someone who hasn't noticed them before. It's Drake and Kendrick. Yes. Yeah, right.

Thank you. I didn't want to say it. But then there's an odd thing as well. We've never had a World Cup before where the administration has seemed to not want people to come.

like we've had authoritarian states like or increasingly authoritarian states or administrations hold world cups before but it's normally a kind of here's our great country we're showing off to now it's almost like here's our country like screw you and that's super weird we've never really seen that before i don't know what's going to come out of this tournament at all because i feel like there are two extra opponents for every team right there's the the travel and there's the political context so actually what i think we're going to see i think we're going to see some really weird results on the field. I think this, psychologically, I think some of this is going to throw up. You know like we had the pandemic and you had like Liverpool losing five games in a row at home or six games in a row at Anfield, the men's team. I think that actually, the effect of what you're going to see on the field, I think that it's going to be a COVID level effect of randomness, weirdness.

You're going to see some really strange outcomes and I would be worried if I was one of the so-called big teams in a group with, let's say, Cabo Verde or DR Congo, I'd be really worried because those teams are coming to cook right they've never qualified for world cup before um caboverd for example they're very good and there's no pressure on them now you think of the teams that have flown there with a ton of pressure on them with all these variables after a long season travel arrangements political context and they're being asked they're being doorstepped about what do you think about the current events administration they're like what we've never been asked about politics before those people are feeling the pressure and i think we're going to see some results in this tournament that could be historic actually i think we're going to see historic upsets i'm hyped for it so what's this podcast all about basically think of us as football soccer time travelers who are going to go back over you know a span of roughly 100 years to revisit these world cup stories where power has tried to influence the tournament okay well I will travel with Julio and Musa anywhere and definitely throughout this podcast. We are going to just look geographically at a lot of places where historically soccer has been used as a tool to fight against political power. It won't be all of them, but there's some good ones in here and I'm so excited. This is your faithful third soccer time traveler.

I've got all the coordinates. I'm locked in, ready to go. We could go much, much deeper these topics, of course. But for now, we are going to encourage you to seek out the incredible books, movies, and podcasts around the topic.

And without further ado, let's get into the episode. So let's start our story. So, okay, y'all, we're going to go on our first journey. But before we head to our first destination, just a little context to the context, right?

Football as we know it, and, you know, as Musa calls it, football. Merida and I have been saying soccer, but, you know, we are saying football. I don't have the accent to say football. I don't have it.

Yeah, I get it. You're now, you know, you're from, you're like in Alabama, you know, you're from Alabama. So like, I get it. But like Moose's, you know, so I'm going to say that football form, you know, as it's recognized today, really started in 1863 when the Football Association in England established the standardized rules, right?

similar games have always existed before like it's not the first time that people were like kicking balls or or objects in you know in in in the time of civilization but the game as we know it today started in 1863 now we're gonna quickly do you know the warp speed this is a part in the time machine where we do the warp speed like a star wars scene it's like boom from 1863 we go to Uruguay in 1930. That is the first FIFA World Cup that was hosted in Uruguay and Uruguay won. Yay, South America. Shout out to my Latin America.

I'm a Latin Americanist. So it's like, who won the first World Cup? It's like Latin Americans. but we're actually going to start the story in a sense at the second World Cup which is in 1934 because a lot of the themes that are cropping up out of that story seem like we're revisiting now and they're actually quite modern and contemporary and very relevant so that's our first stop in this series Where are you seeing the relevance in the modern day?

Well, Mussolini. Go for it, go for it. And you want to talk about, hey, I'm creating a fascist society. Oh, look what I have.

Look what just showed up on my lap. An international global competition that maybe I can manipulate and many argue fix so that the Italians could win. and Italian glory is, you know, sport, Italian sports glory is tied to Italian nationalism in a time in Europe and in the world where fascism was in vogue. And do I dare say that fascism is still in vogue now or more in vogue now in certain parts of this world, Musa?

I mean, you know i think it's i think it's a i think there's a strong argument that it is uh very much i'm leading the witness i'm leading my fellow time traveler well look i'll let merit jump in in a sec but um while you say all of this it's interesting because we're seeing obviously right now a vast accumulation of power and wealth at the top of society absolutely we're seeing that and i think it's interesting because in 1934 you had a superb Italy team. I'm not sure you have the same quality of team, one of the main hosts with the United States. But I think there are some parallels, right, in terms of the leadership, the consolidation of power. But there's something strange about the projection of power.

So I think, am I correct to say that in the current moment, there's a projection of power, but there's not necessarily a desire to be seen as a higher form of civilization. It's more a kind of take it or leave it. But I feel like the mood was different. It was a different project.

The Italian project back in Mussolini's time, at least, was to project, I don't know, maybe a higher form of civilization as opposed to a kind of winner-takes-all. Is that a fair estimation of what was going on back then? I'd love to know more, but I do think from its basic points, what this 1934 World Cup establishes is how football, how soccer is becoming part of the foundation of a political thing, right? A political tournament where power, where like being close to power is important.

So I think the relevance of when you see the FIFA president hand out, you know, all of a sudden we have the first, what is it? The first annual like peace award from FIFA. Wow. Who got it?

You know, the, the current president of the United States, and this was pre-Iran, where it's like, I'm for peace, and I get a peace award. And it's, you know, the fix is in. So I do think the topic of Mussolini with trying to control the outcome to make sure that the Italians win in 1934 was pretty clear. Now, do I think Donald Trump is like, trying to manipulate the World Cup for the United States team to win?

I'm like, no. and I think the only place he's trying not to manipulate because he doesn't understand soccer say more merit I think that but I think that's a point I think when you see someone like Mussolini where you see the Italian football tradition it's pretty clear and the Italians got their own issues they didn't make the tournament this year so like you know that was a massive tragedy but say more about that I think like in like what we're going to talk about this with Mussolini. Mussolini like saw soccer as like, hey, this is good for the country. This is going to elevate Italy.

I don't think Trump knows the game. So like, I think this is fascinating what you're saying. I believe that Trump wants or will do things to elevate his own personal brand. Right?

Like he's going to agree or, you know, manipulate the stock market for his own personal gain. He's going to do all these to elevate his own brand, where when I look at Benito Mussolini, he wanted Italy to be on the world stage, this political powerhouse. And to Musa's point, Italy in that time was, to be a part of the national team was a badge of honor. It was very prestigious.

You don't have that same power in the U.S. men's national team that Italy saw in their national team to portray or continue to push this political identity, but also the identity of the actual being that Mussolini wanted Italians to really take on. He believed that soccer was a vehicle to further push this ideology of what it meant to be this Italian man. If I'm I believe I'm correct in saying that.

No, you are. And what you said, Merritt, I absolutely agree in the sense of, you know. Yeah, I think if the U.S. men's team does well, Trump's going to jump in and be like, oh, look how great they are.

But I have serious concerns as a very passionate US men's soccer fan that they're even going to advance to the round of 16. But with that said, when we set the stage of this is happening in Italy, let's remember in March of 1934, Benito Mussolini, his fascist party, rigged the election to solidify their control of Italy. Right. Like, you know, this whole notion of like who gets to win, who rigs, you know, so like we know that we know that in 1934 and then this is in March and then like the tournament happened later in the year.

We know that there was strict surveillance and propaganda tools in place. So I'll give you one example. This this organization in Italy called OVRA, O-V-R-A, the Organization for Vigilance and Repression of Anti-Fascism. There was secret police.

There was mandatory youth groups. There was strict censorship. There was monitoring of people's private lives. That doesn't sound far off of what's happening in parts, you know, in the United States.

There was a rise of anti-Semitism. There were policies put in place to restrict Jewish people from holding public office. You know, 1934 was the year that Hitler consolidated power in Germany and declared himself the Fuhrer. And, you know, that was what was happening.

And yes, this Italian team in 1934 was really strong. and Benito Mussolini was like yo like if we win the world cup like Italy like it's had you know Italy's had some problems over the last 200 years in relevance in global politics but this is going to put me on the top so that is clear so I do see a lot of like similarities to that I wanted to jump in as well like a key part of this was we were talking before this episode began we were kind of spitballing in the green room about the inherent unpredictability of soccer right and it's as things to hang your hat on if you're trying to kind of create a new masculinity a new nationalism soccer is one of the riskier things to pin it on right like so many things can go wrong but this Italy team was a great team right it won this world cup and spoiler it won the next one as well how did Mussolini do it how did he engage with the players and are there any indications that they were actually into this themselves politically personally professionally is there any sense does history give us any indication they were actually died in the war fascists are just kind of along for the ride i mean i do think one thing to consider is when you live in a fascist society and you have to like survive and you're a national italian player who loves the sport and says maybe i don't agree with this guy but i really love the game i think it's a really good question i don't have that sense of like what were the italians thinking but we can say that whatever you say about italy at the time mussolini resonated i mean 1934 like he was the man he was el duche you know like but but what was what was interesting is i am 100 certain from what i've studied and read that you mentioned 34 and you mentioned 38 doesn't hurt to have a winning world cup like you know back-to-back champion while you're trying to like manipulate nationalism and play off propaganda and make sure you're like you know you know repressing your people because they don't agree with you but then it's like yay we won two world cups in a row so i mean it's classic sports manipulation propaganda i mean i don't see it as a lost loss for muzzalini going back to moose's original question i'm i'm curious if there's a pathway here to kind of lean into this ideology of were players bought in was the coaching staff brought in was there a shift in any tactics or ideology from this italian national team that kind of would further uphold this fascist image and the new italian man all right i'm gonna give you a sports quest like a sports answer to this because you played the game. Musa, you are surrounded by, you know, you are a lover and player of the game. I play the game and we've all been, I mean, I've not been on the same pitch that Merritt has been, but I've been in the culture of being a soccer team.

And one of the most specific examples of this that Mussolini sort of instituted was this notion of rigging and bringing in friendly referees, knowing like, so he brought these referees from like Sweden to like favor the Italians. And so, because they were very physical, right? So there were these blatant, multiple blatant controversial, like pre-VAR type of calls that no one could, you know, that people were like, was totally favor the Italians, right? This notion of rigging for Italian male superiority as a player, like, let's be honest.

Do you all really love referees? like like no player loves a referee so if you knew that the refs were playing in your favor and musolini's like yo i got you just play your game you guys are strong italians go win this tournament i got these swedish referees who are gonna like give you the calls in your favor so go tackle go be cheap like this notion which is kind of like ironic to what you're saying merit because when you're like oh the fast you know the new italian male like he's noble he's you know this sort of fascist ideology but when in fact when it came to tactics when it came to in-game tactics it's like we had to put the refs on the payroll we had to bribe them and you can say what you want about players whether they're like respectful for the game and the code of conduct they all want to win do you want to win merit like when you're on the pitch do you want to lose i do want to win but i think there would be something about the competitive nature that's completely flawed inherently knowing that the refs are on my side so something else merit i want to jump in there because i feel there's something about i see that and i think this this this national sentiment there's something else i think that goes on i think when you're wearing the shirt of the national team and you're on this tide of emotion you're the host nation and you're closely aligned with you know there's varying degrees it seems of of alignment with Mussolini's core political goals but fundamentally a lot of those players wanted the glory and they wanted easy life I mean look at like a good example so Giuseppe Meazza the star player right the San Siro stadium is named after him right like if you think of his iconic status in Italy it's not like he's a forgotten a name because he was aligned with Mussolini it's quite the opposite so I suppose at some level like base ambition takes over look at the 78 world cup actually the 78 world cup merits a good example too like you have a tournament that many people regard as being rigged Argentina win that Passarella the captain and the champion he goes on to even greater heights after that and I almost think to myself I don't know Mary I think that I think you're an anomaly because I think this is intoxicating the idea of being i think people got caught up in the spectacle it seems like i well that's the basic question and merit first of all kudos i i love i was like it's like i i get it because i'm type of that player too where it's like why like in my own little stupid over the league playing that you tell me i shouldn't do anymore i you know i kind of respect the ref but there's plenty of like some plays guys you know people i play against who are always trying to have the ref on their favor. So I get that. But here's the question that this all begs, which I think is really, really important.

So if you are a person operating under a suppressive fascist regime, do you need to be told explicitly to act in that said regime's favor? Or are you able to absorb that pressure and just accept it? Because fear is, you know, is absorbing that pressure based on fear or is it based on this quest for glory or is it just manifested in saying like i just gotta shut up and and like pass the soccer ball and there's a rate like this is a rig game i know we're gonna win this game and i want that glory like you mentioned that musa like to me that's the big question is like what is going through the minds of these footballers and are you acquiescing to power because you want the power you want the glory you want to be that great italian because this person came in and blamed everyone for the ills against italy and say what you want mussolini had appeal and i know that sounds really people will be like oh that's controversial it's like no it's not i mean the guy stayed you know like people like he rigged the election but he was there so were there you know so did the world cup become a place to be like you know what i mean it's like there's this acceptance of the system because you want the nationalist glory so i'm going to toss it out to the two of you to think about that so that's the deep question of this episode merit you take that first because i've got thoughts but i'm winding up i'm winding up my swing you started it with the whole like deep question about like italian virility and all this And then, you know, like, I don't think ref should, you know, I don't agree that ref, you know, you're like, I wouldn't act that way. So here you go.

I sit here and I come back to this point of, you know, the line, shut up and dribble. you're an athlete and this this thing that is bigger than you which is ultimately this political push to write a narrative drive hone a narrative that whether you assimilate to or you don't they're likely in this fascist society was the expectation that you would adhere to what Mussolini is asking of you and within that you will find glory you will find success you will gain riches and that's inherently what is the ugliness of fascism and to align with that continues to like push through and uphold the system that really not only undermines society but it undermines even the people that are actively participating in the support for your particular sport you know what's funny merrick can i just jump in yeah you're talking about um this glory and this obsession there's something about fascism i want to pinpoint what you brought up there's like a whitewashing effect right what fascism does very well fascism is obsessed with two things it's obsessed with purity and it's obsessed with the eternal right and there's something about the cleansing effect of the spectacle of like holding up a world cup trophy with everyone in the nation supposedly aligned in pursuit of this glory merit sorry to jump in but you got me thinking about you got me thinking about the super bowl actually you know like how prior to the super bowl you had like when the baltimore ravens one of their key players i think lewis was basically like implicated in some pretty shady stuff yeah and he wins he wins the the super bowl all of a sudden he's like football football football and then you have like um ben rothlisberger when he won a couple of super bowls and all the conversations around him now that are coming out but at the time the sporting victory was allowed to kind of push all that stuff to the side because it was all about the city pride and i feel like i feel like looking back at the italy tournament in 34 a similar thing happened like the idea was that this was some pure tournament that italy won fair and square ostensibly but actually like i think uruguay hadn't even gone to the tournament because right they boycott it yeah uruguay didn't even go to the tournament right so it wasn't even it wasn't even like italy's tournament to kind of your girl wasn't there to defend it italy win and then if you look at a lot of their sort of their current identity is based on that victory and it's not that we haven't had incredible italian football since then but if we think of the founding myth like the modern when we think of italy now we think of like a football is one of the core strengths mary i feel like it kind of worked you know during the 1934 world cup when you go when you look at the the archival footage and when you look at the photos there were fascist symbols everywhere right and the crowds were encouraged to like project this nationalistic fervor for Italy, especially the Italian crowds, that made other teams and their fans feel inherently unsafe, right? So this notion of here we are pushing fascism, like in this tournament, and there's people in that stadium are like, what the hell's going on here? This is not what I signed up for, right?

So that's number one. And to the point that You just said, Musa, like you said, Uruguay boycotted the tournament. So we can look at it from a sporting perspective saying, well, the defending champion wasn't even there. So how important, you know, how big of a win was it for Italy to begin with?

Because the team that won the Cup in 1930 wasn't there to defend it. And the reasons why they weren't there is that they were a South American team. And this was like a decision. They felt like xenophobia.

and it was a story about sort of, you know, how even the World Cup back in the day already had this sort of Eurocentricity based in fascism. And then you had, you know, South American teams. And believe me, I'm not getting, you know, I don't want to get into a Latin American history debate here. It wasn't like fascism wasn't part of the Latin American experience in the 30s, but it wasn't as prevalent and as concentrated as, say, you know, Germany and Italy.

But at the same time, You know, they were already laying the groundwork for a mass boycott in the 1938 Cup on the part of America because France was hosting it in 1938. So you saw a lot of the majority South American and Central American teams saying, like, we're not going to participate. so already this notion of hey this is a you know the early origins of the political like to go back to the point of like the political foundation of the world cup was already being challenged and it wasn't like everyone was like lockstep into like yay mazzolini like this is where we're gonna be if you knew that your professional games or your the national caps that you played like we're all rigged like and you all won the game let's say you won and you got all the glory and you got all the endorsements but you knew in your heart that you know whoever was organizing this like set was say i'm gonna help you i've got another hot take yeah but how would that help take for both of you i've just had a yeah but i want to know what merit has to think first right like like would you be like oh this accomplishment would that lead to like you trading in the glory to knowing that that was rigged would you make that choice like to be like i don't want the glory because this wasn't done fairly the best way i can the best way i can probably put this for the listener in terms of what that feeling i think would inherently feel like for me listen i played my career for a very long time there were championships i was a part of i was either injured or did not play in the same way that i believe that i should play in those games. Those games in terms of me owning them and in being like, I won this championship doesn't sit the same as when I am starting playing, actively participating in all the playoff rounds and all of those things.

That is what I take pride in because I was actively a part of that moment that that really feels something that I'm attached to. And when you start to lose that bit of attachment for me I think it would be hard to look back and reflect on winning a world cup and knowing that the entire thing was rigged in my favor there would be something inherently that yeah you can own that thing but you deep down know you didn't participate in that in that winning experience in the same way if it was a fairly held world cup and I think if you can kind of break that down, like not everyone has ever know the amount of people that will participate in a world cup, very few to win a world cup, even less. But I think for the viewer, you can think back to that thing or the listener, if you can think back to something that you're a part of, and it didn't feel like you're really a part of that thing and how that sits and how that very same thing can sit so differently when you feel that you were a part of it in this fair way and you actively participated in it, I think that gives you some form of the feeling that I have when I take on this question. Meanwhile, in the United States, in 1934, Franklin Delano Roosevelt broke this longstanding pattern of sitting presidents losing support during midterm elections, which is very rare.

In fact, the Democrats gained power in the House, and they solidified these New Deal policies. so you know that was the context of the world and then this was also happening the 1934 world cup was also happening during the great depression and it stilted and complicated qualifications for for that that year's cup so this highly globalized sporting event taking place during a year of great political transition. The World Cup, you know, this World Cup, the 1934 World Cup was seen as an opportunity to project power and strength. We know that basically, you know, basically soccer is massively impactful on a global stage.

That's definitely a takeaway here. And it's going to help to ground the political organizing we go on to talk about in other episodes with real stakes. But to understand why the rebellions are so meaningful, we need to help listeners understand the magnitude of the sport and its political power as recognized by world leaders. And the 1934 World Cup, in that context of this is a moment to uplift my power, was very clear with Italy and Mussolini.

Musa, you have a hot take about this? I mean, Merritt just gave the players perspective. and Mary, thank you for the honesty on that. You're welcome.

Musa, what about you? I was really just feeling that we talk about the player's perspective and the glory that comes from that and as a supporter, and it feels like the great victory is actually just getting to host the tournament in the first place. Winning is a bonus and it provides great photo ops, but actually to say that you hold a World Cup, we look at the world right now, right? What is the world basically based on?

In the age of social media, it's an attention economy, right? So it's not even important what people are saying about you it's that they are talking about you and the fact that like italy got to host the world cup in 1934 the world came to italy like even if the italian team had not done that well in the tournament the fact that you all have to pay attention to italy for an entire month of the year is enough and i wonder if that's going to be enough for the us look we did all these things but and you may not like them but we're doing them and that's actually what this is about i remember like was the world cup in qatar mary as well when you saw i was talking i said you can tell where power is by the people who've come to that final you know like trump's inauguration we had all the tech bosses start sitting in a line yeah and it was like the old like medieval courts it felt like the world cup final looking at looking at that and like there were people who talked to their comms teams and their personal handlers going i have to be in that stadium because that's where power is and the fascinating thing about fascism is that it always knows where to find power so i think the true trophy i think was was getting to host it in the first place i mean i think that leads to sort of the key takeaways of the 1934 world cup like what do we make of this i think your point about hosting it we are going to be you know it's very clear that Benito Mussolini, after he wins, goes like, I just got this massive gift. And I am going to use this hosting opportunity to uplift my power to the world. Because you might think Italy is this backwards little country.

And you know, we've had our issues. And you know, if you look at the history of Italy, and not to get into an Italian history lesson, but you know, when it comes to like the countries of europe it wasn't in the influence of power and let's not forget you know they like to remind people that the roman you know the roman empire was there so like there was this sort of you know going back to the greatness of italia so this hosting of the world cup where and to bring it to places like qatar and like what's happening what's going to happen in the United States. And what you said, Merit, previously about how unattainable it is, how the tournament has become for the uber powerful and rich to be like, I want to be at the World Cup final because that's where the power is. I think it's fair to say that Benito Mussolini was thinking ahead and realizing that this little tournament that started in Uruguay in 1930 as this idea and then moved to Italy he saw it as a massive political opportunity to to say what you just said Musa this notion of I you know I need to be at this final because I'm going to be close to power so I don't know if you all have other takeaways about that so you look at like Uruguay we mentioned it before Uruguay boycotted right there's an argument that actually by doing that they played the long game they preserved their power and their aura because they won the world cup in 1950 and they're still now the team that nobody really wants to play even they're playing i love the fact that every time you bring up you you have this knack in this time travel not to interrupt you that you just ground us in like the football in the results like you have become our encyclopedic world cup like i need to remind you that uruguay held out they boycotted there was solidarity with other like south american countries and then they kept played the long game and won again in 1950 that's resistance i think it's i think it's identity you know what it is julio i think someone once said that memory is resistance right and i think the the idea that you stand for your ideals no matter what happens you had like was senegal at the recent for those who didn't get a chance to watch it senegal in the recent african cup of nations they basically walked off the pitch right in protest at a decision for morocco in the recent african cup of nations final and some would criticize their decision to walk off but actually there's something quite powerful about saying that the outcome of a sporting fixture is not the most important thing about the fixture right there's something important in going actually and maybe this is in the time of resistance and saying no to things and boycotting or whatever people choose to do or not to do there is another way you don't have to go for the circus but who knows we know that like italy built their founding myth of that world cup but what if uruguay gone to that world cup and been heartbroken by the match by the match fixing do they end up as great or do they go back home do they stay at home and go actually we stood tall we said no to this circus and we sat at home and we built something really special and enduring like you don't always have to turn up at the circus if all you're going to find are clowns right and i think i look at the uruguay thing and i wonder at the time it was like hang on a minute we should stand tall we should go and compete and actually people watching that merit i think thinking from a sporting perspective the game is rigged like we're not going to go overseas cross an ocean and like basically serve as handmaidens foot soldiers for fascism to roll out the red carpet like does that make sense oh yeah totally i think that you know the point is is for this world cup i i'm just in in this imaginary world if there were a team to do what uruguay did who would you who would you say would be a team that would benefit from not participating in the 2026 world cup i'll jump in very quickly hudu no no it's a great question because i tell you what i don't want to throw a country under the bus i don't want to make it the role of an individual country to push back against what the u.s is doing i would love the final to be hosted elsewhere i would love a parallel tournament to be hosted like elsewhere like or just something as a kind of parallel you know in the old days you had these kind of you had two popes back in the day i thought there should be like two fifas what can we take from this specific story to instruct how we how we navigate our current moment and i think you've already started to answer these what i'm hearing is soccer can be resistance on so many levels like take the case of uruguay it was like we're not playing.

We're the champions. We're not playing. This isn't right. This is going to be rigged.

This is Mussolini. They're being xenophobic. They don't like South American, Central American countries. They think they're better than us.

So we're not showing up. So that's one form of resistance. The other form of resistance that I'm hearing is on a level playing field, you always have the opportunity to do something great and shake power. And soccer can shake power.

So even though the United States with the Trump administration is going to set this up as like, you know, think about, I think about that scene from Rocky with Apollo Creed at the end in the first where it's like, I am the champ, you know, it's the bicentennial thing and Rocky's there, he's the underdog and Apollo Creed's coming in with like red, white, and blue and like, you know, magic patriotic music, take that and multiply it by 3000. Cause that's what we're going to get in the United States of America in the middle of the World Cup. And I feel that anyone who sees sort of that level of resistance, you can resist. What you said, Merit, the best way to fight against fascism is to call it out for what it is, and it's evil, and it's hyper-capitalism.

And the fact that it is unequal, the fact that we're going to be in a tournament where people will not have, You know, people love this game, but they won't be able to see it. Right. So, so many issues that I hope our time traveling will take us in different places. But, you know, are there any last thoughts about this before we, we, you know, shut down the time machine and, you know, prep for the next episode?

Before we, before we leap to the, before we leap back in the time machine, I've got a quick thought. I was watching one of my favorite Instagram theorists, Louisa Cherry, I think, and she was talking about this book, The Pedagogy of the Oppressed, Paulo Freire, and about how it's really important to call a thing what it is. A lot of people don't like using the word fascism, but I think first you have to diagnose it before you deal with it. The second thing is, as a takeaway, this is a circus.

So fascism operates on two things, optics and sentiment, right? So you've got to take every opportunity to disrupt the optics and the sentiment. You've got to constantly remind people, even if you lose the game even if you go out like six nil in each game you have to do something in the course of each game and i would say maybe as a supporter or as a member of the diaspora that has a bit more agency because those poor iranian players a lot of them have got relatives back home and they can't do stuff because the regime is watching and we've seen what happens to iranian players like ali die who speak out they become outcasts right so we've seen that so basically take every opportunity to disrupt and because everyone remembers the 2018 world cup final when Russian protesters run on the pitch and shake hands with Mbappe. And that was one intervention.

Can you imagine, like, with all the games being played and all the countries that are playing, the opportunities, given the size of the World Cup and the distance being played over, the opportunities for disruption, especially those games not even being taking place in the US itself, the opportunities for disruption are absolutely manifold. Anything. It could be from, like, blockading a team bus. so the kickoff happens like two hours late like it could be anything the smallest acts of disruption i think could define this world cup merit final thoughts on that last question you continuing to get reminded throughout this conversation and even pulling in other mega sporting events the olympics that you often get opportunity where it's two competing countries it's these two ideologies of countries over and over again that sit in this championship game or this very highlighted group stage game that it just feels more weighted and it feels like it has a bigger impact than just winning and losing.

Is this moment in time going to solidify what we're seeing currently in the United States or is it going to thoroughly disrupt what the current actions are of this administration? And to Musa's point, I think what I want to see in this World Cup is disruption over and over again, specifically in the United States, because this administration and the way it's treated the people of this country and the way that it's incited fear, it's made people uncomfortable. It's made people question whether they're safe going to something that is so globally recognized as the best sporting event in the world. They have taken that shine away from people.

They have made it a barrier where it's not even possible for so many to even enter. And for that reason, it needs to be called out. It needs to be disrupted. And it needs the backing of people with a platform to be willing to say this is not right.

And in those moments that are on a scale that are highlighted and televised, that those moments are taken and they are used as a form of resistance time and time again. Well, I just want to say, yeah, I'm so glad I said yes to this project. just for our first conversation. I'm already thinking of like, we are a cohesive team.

We are like soccer players. We're all bringing in our own skills, but together it just felt right. So I want to thank the both of you for letting me sort of be the first person to drive our time machine journey into 1934. into Italy.

So thank you so much, the both of you. And I'm looking forward to the rest of the episodes with the both of you. And if someone gets to drive the time machine in the next episode. So I appreciate this from the bottom of my heart.

Thank you so much. Thank you. Yeah, thank you. This has been a wonderful journey.

And I can't wait for all the others. But I must know who is our nine in this group who is our attacking midfielder who is our I feel like I feel like I'm the eight I think I was the eight in this one as a host because I was kind of like making sure I got a control we got to seeing your connecting feed so I might play the nine in another episode I don't know about you Musa I thought Musa was definitely like you know you you and Musa were definitely are attacking our attack and I was just I think I was offside a few times so let me uh let me just you know any attacker is always going to think that they're offside they're never offside so it was definitely a um a one two formation uh so and that's the way we're going to be set up with three players yeah we got a two front we got a two front we got a two front a nine that operates with seven or eleven maybe but yeah it's good i just hope that you know if i'm on the attack down this time time travel journey and someone else hopefully you I hope I don't hit a little notch in the pitch. Hopefully I don't get injured. But thank you again.

Yeah, Musa. Thank you again, Musa and Merit. Yeah, beautiful game. Thank you.

All right. Thank you. Our Copa is hosted by Merit Mathias, Musa Okwonga, and Julio Ricardo Varela. Produced by Emma Foley and executive produced by Carrie Toles and Clark Sonderman of TCBPR.

with support from Working Families Power and Mijente Support Committee. featuring music by Pedazo de Carne Conojo and graphics by Caroline Speyer. For more information on how to organize around this year's World Cup and to find an event near you, visit www.ourcopa.com or at ourcopa26 on Instagram.

Episode notes · Notas del episodio

On Our Copa’s pilot episode, Julio, Musa, and Merritt explore the political exploitation of soccer for authoritarian gains, the ongoing impact of boycotts, and the modern parallels to the second ever world cup.

Credits · Créditos

Our Copa is hosted by Merritt Mathias, Musa Okwonga, and Julio Ricardo Varela Produced by Emma Foley and executive produced by Carrie Tolles and Clarke Sondermann of TCB PR with support from Working Families Power and Mijente Support Committee. featuring music by Pedazo De Carne Con Ojo and graphics by Caroline Spire For more information on how to organize around this year’s World Cup and to find an event near you, visit  www.ourcopa.com Follow us on Instagram: @ourcopa26 @okwonga @julito77  @merrmerr9